Visit The Syria Report Subscribe to our mailing list
EN ع
  • Twitter
Syria Report
  • Green Tabu
    • Issues
    • Updates
    • Analysis
    • Policy Briefs
    • Interviews
  • Archive
    • All articles
    • News
    • Analysis & Features
    • Reports & Papers
    • Regulations
    • Directory
  • Search
  • Menu Menu
Home1 / earthquake2

Posts

Prefabricated Temporary Housing for Earthquake Evacuees

20-06-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

The first report to be issued by the operations rooms put in place in Syria’s earthquake-stricken governorates, issued on March 14, 2023, confirmed the existence of a medium-term approach to address the housing issue for those affected by the February 6 disaster. This approach involves installing prefabricated housing units to accommodate and host the affected families. It appears that there is a governmental directive to fund these units solely through international or regional donors, such as Iraq, the UAE and China.

Due to the lack of clarity and precise data about this approach, it can be concluded from the information published about it in the official media, that it falls under the second medium-term phase of the national action plan to deal with the aftermath of the earthquake, which was announced by the Council of Ministers on February 25 and approved on April 25.

In these projects, there is a variance in designations and terminologies; from shelter units to temporary housing, or pre-fabricated or alternative housing. In determining the characteristics of this type of housing, this article will use the name: temporary prefabricated housing units for earthquake victims. In all cases, official statements on the subject vary, and contradictions appear in the numbers of these units, their areas, the areas of the zones allocated for them. It is worth noting that the governorates of Aleppo and Lattakia have specified sites for the construction of these homes, while regional and international entities have taken on the task of building the units. A single site can include contributions from more than one grantor.

 

Iraqi Popular Mobilisation Forces

Prime Minister Hussein Arnous inspected a site in Jabrin area east of Aleppo city, during his visit to Aleppo on June 10, designated for the establishment of 332 temporary prefabricated housing units for earthquake victims. The project is being implemented by the Iraqi Relief Mobilisation, a civil arm of the Iraqi Popular Mobilisation Forces, a militia composed of armed Iraqi Shiite factions loyal to the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC).

The operations room for the Aleppo governorate adopted a plan in March, the details of which were not revealed, to construct temporary prefabricated housing units for those affected by the earthquake, on a 50-hectare area in Jabrin, located near Aleppo International Airport and surrounded by the Sheikh Najjar industrial city and the Aleppo train station. Jabrin was incorporated into the administrative boundaries of Aleppo city in 1996. In 2017, a shelter centre and camps for displaced people were established there.

Aleppo Governor Hussein Diab stated to the media during a visit to the Iraqi Relief Mobilisation project in Jabrin, on April 9, that the installation of the temporary housing units represents a new stage on the road to recovery and a significant point in transitioning from collective shelters. Aleppo governorate has taken responsibility for levelling and preparing the land and carrying out infrastructure works.

On April 15, the state-run SANA news agency announced that technical work crews from the Iraqi Relief Mobilisation initiative, in cooperation with the Aleppo governorate, completed 100 prefabricated units in Jabrin. A member of the executive office in the governorate council said that the governorate of Aleppo has allocated a 13-hectare area in Jabrin to the Iraqi Mobilisation Relief initiative.

The coordinator of the Iraqi initiative, Ghaleb Al-Husseini, told SANA, on April 15 that the project aims to set eventually 500 housing units, 100 of which have been completed and are ready for delivery. Each unit covers an area of 36 square metres, consisting of two bedrooms and a salon, equipped with a solar panel. The units are constructed with iron as the main material used in manufacturing. The units also include sound and thermal insulation materials. These units will be equipped with necessary household furniture for family life, and each one can accommodate six to eight people. Husseini indicated that the first phase of the project is expected to be completed within two months, including the delivery of 300 units.

 

China

In late May, the Minister of Local Administration and Environment Hussein Makhlouf, along with the Chinese ambassador to Syria, Xi Hongoi, signed a document to receive prefabricated units, donated by the Chinese people for the earthquake victims. The Syrian minister stated that the units would be distributed equally between the governorates of Aleppo and Lattakia. These units are part of a plan for medium-term housing centres, and they can be used as mobile clinics or classrooms, depending on the needs of the schools, or as temporary kitchens for shelter centres, among other uses.

The director of the cargo transport regulation office in Aleppo governorate told the Athr Press website on April 20 that a convoy of 13 trucks transported 25 containers containing 100 prefabricated units from a Chinese ship that arrived at Lattakia port to the Jabrin area in Aleppo. The remaining homes are expected to arrive on other ships.

The Lattakia governorate received its share of prefabricated units from China as reported by Al-Watan newspaper, on April 10. An executive office member in Lattakia governorate explained that the donation, which arrived on the ship Lady Mia, included 228 housing units inside 57 containers. These were handed over to the Syrian Arab Red Crescent (SARC) for distribution to the locations and areas designated by the governorate for the setting of temporary housing for those affected by the earthquake.

The executive office member added that those who will benefit from these units are the earthquake victims whose homes were destroyed and lost in the quake, or those whose homes were damaged and are at risk of collapse. This is according to a specific mechanism that includes the actual victims. The official did not clarify what this specific mechanism is, but he explained that each housing unit consists of one room and its facilities, with an area ranging between 40-50 square metres.

 

United Arab Emirates

In a press conference held in Lattakia on April 17, the head of the United Arab Emirates Red Crescent delegation, Mohammed Al-Kaibi, said that the UAE would construct 1,000 prefabricated housing units for those affected by the earthquake in Lattakia governorate. During the inauguration of the first prefabricated housing unit in Lattakia city’s Al-Gharraf neighbourhood on April 6, Kaibi stated that the purpose of these units is to ease pressure on shelter centres. He added that these would act as temporary shelter centres, comprising 1,000 housing units distributed over seven areas.

The Lattakia governorate earmarked seven sites for the establishment of prefabricated housing projects, as follows: three sites in Lattakia city – two in Al-Gharraf neighbourhood and one in Damsarkho. In the Jableh area, three sites were identified in the neighbourhoods of Al-Naka, Al-Fawar and Al-Faid, and one site was identified in Astamo in the Qardaha area.

The Relief Operations Room in the Lattakia governorate indicated that work would begin at Al-Gharraf. Each housing unit measures 42 square metres and follows a standard design. The Relief Operations Room added that coordination is ongoing with international organisations for the funding of temporary streets, pavements, public lighting and medical points for these projects. Meanwhile, the Governor of Lattakia projected that the completion period would be between six and eight months, including the provision of infrastructure such as water and electricity networks and sewage systems at the sites.

During a meeting with the directors of service and construction agencies in the governorate on April 16, the Lattakia governor stressed the need to expedite the implementation of infrastructure at the sites set aside for the Emirati housing units. He highlighted the necessity for regular monitoring of all the sites and speedy implementation of services and infrastructure, which would help in reducing the delivery time of the completed housing units.

The semi-official newspaper Al-Watan reported on May 9 that the mayor of Qammin, which includes the Astamo village, stated that the UAE project had temporarily halted due to the lack of suitable public land within the Qammin municipality’s jurisdiction. Therefore, the municipality suggested leasing a land for a period of 40 years with automatic renewal, which was rejected by the Ministry of Local Administration. The Ministry insisted on buying a piece of land at an appropriate price and establishing temporary housing units on it. As Al-Watan reported later, the Ministry’s insistence on purchasing the land was due to its desire to ensure the project’s future stability, serving the affected and the administrative unit in general. Indeed, on May 18, the Lattakia governorate council approved Qammin municipality’s request, granting it a donation of SYP 210 million to buy a piece of land to establish temporary homes for those affected by the earthquake in Astamo, with the UAE Red Crescent as the implementing party. 

On May 9, the official SANA news agency reported that the Lattakia governorate had begun legal procedures to transfer the land ownership in Astamo, prior to its preparation and commencement of construction work. The land, measuring 10 dunums and capable of accommodating 85 prefabricated housing units, is expected to have a completed housing project within eight months. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-06-20 15:55:302024-03-04 15:01:55Prefabricated Temporary Housing for Earthquake Evacuees

Earthquake Committees in SIG-Controlled Areas

06-06-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

Engineering committees that were formed by the Free Syrian Engineers’ Syndicate in northern Syria will work until the end of June to inspect and assess damages caused by the February 6 earthquake. The work comes as part of a comprehensive survey project for buildings and other facilities aimed at inspecting damages to private, public and governmental buildings as well as services in areas controlled by the Turkish-backed Syrian Interim Government (SIG). 

According to Khaled Al-Othman, head of the Free Syrian Engineers’ Syndicate branch in Aleppo, the survey project began on February 16, 2023, after the initial emergency response period to the earthquake had ended. The project includes 27 “comprehensive survey committees”, each consisting of three engineers, one of whom is a structural consulting engineer to serve as the team leader. 

As of May 29, 2023, the committees have inspected 33,087 buildings in the rural northern part of Aleppo governorate, covering 82 cities, towns, villages and settlements. Of those buildings, two percent were fully destroyed; three percent were severely damaged; 19 percent were moderately damaged; 38 percent were slightly damaged; and 38 percent were still safe. The committees also inspected 105 schools as of May 29, one of which was fully destroyed. Eight schools were severely damaged and 30 were moderately damaged. 

The syndicate also formed three public safety committees tasked with studying the results and reports of the comprehensive survey committees, though only for the buildings that were classified as severely damaged. Afterward, these public safety committees will reinspect the buildings and give their final engineering opinion on whether they should be demolished, removed and their rubble cleared away; or whether the buildings can remain and undergo reinforcement. The three public safety committees are distributed geographically between Azaz, Afrin and Jandares. 

As of May 29, these public safety committees had reassessed 609 of the 992 buildings classified as severely damaged. They transferred the results of these assessments to the demolition and removal committees of various local councils, which have the final say on whether to demolish the buildings. Those demolition committees are composed of three consulting engineers from the Free Syrian Engineers Syndicate, as well as a lawyer and two representatives from the relevant local council and public prosecution. 

So far the demolition and removal committee in Jandares has demolished 39 buildings, 25 of which were done as part of a partnership between local councils and NGOs, and 13 in partnership with the Syrian Civil Defence (also known as the White Helmets). Meanwhile, during the same period, the committee in Afrin demolished and removed three buildings. Some of these demolitions were full in scope and meant tearing down the entire structure, while others were only partial and preserved some parts of the buildings that were still intact and would not be impacted by the demolition of damaged sections — especially ground storeys and basements. 

Through consulting engineers who are members of these demolition and removal committees, the role of the Free Syrian Engineers Syndicate has been to suggest appropriate methods for demolition of each building. The syndicate is also meant to monitor the demolition process in order to maintain public safety and the safety of neighbouring buildings. 

Notably, the Free Syrian Lawyers Syndicate, which is active in opposition-held areas, did not play a key role in following up on the earthquake’s impacts to housing, land and property rights. Instead, the syndicate has been limited to its usual rights and judicial roles, without connection to the demolition of earthquake-damaged buildings, Syndicate Council Secretary Youssef Al-Hussein told The Syria Report. However, lawyers who are members of the syndicate have participated on an individual level in the demolition and removal committees by following up on the legal conditions for those impacted by the damage and helping them obtain documents confirming their rights.  

The Free Engineers Syndicate, meanwhile, is working on a set of standards and criteria for proper building reinforcement methods. They held an engineering conference at the Free University of Aleppo for this purpose on April 5 where participants presented and discussed various studies and research papers. The conference decided to adopt the Syrian Arab Code for the Design and Implementation of Reinforced Concrete Structures and its earthquakes appendix, as well as recommendations related to studies on reinforcement. Such studies are meant to be done separately for each building, and the responsibility for structural reinforcement lies with the local councils and at the expense of the property owners.

In this context, the Jandares local council issued a decision on May 31 stating that any cracked building that undergoes reinforcement without the council’s approval would be considered unlicensed construction. This decision was meant to ensure the application of proper standards for reinforcing cracked buildings, as well as the need for engineering committees to supervise such work. 

Meanwhile, Civil Defence teams have nearly finished removing the rubble of buildings damaged by the earthquake, in accordance with the comprehensive action plan announced on March 9. Deputy Civil Defence Director Mounir Al-Mustafa told The Syria Report that the organisation’s teams have almost finished removing the rubble, and so far have cleared away more than 400,000 square metres of debris from more than 120,000 residential communities. They have also cleared roads in 197 residential communities and done 540 projects to remove cracked walls or roofs in 99 communities. Finally, they have prepared and filled 303,519 square metres of land in SIG-controlled areas. with rubble left behind by the earthquake after recycling it.  

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-06-06 21:12:382023-06-07 08:00:59Earthquake Committees in SIG-Controlled Areas

Lattakia Residents Face Uncertainty After Earthquake

30-05-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

Since the earthquake on February 06, some owners of damaged properties in Lattakia still do not know what could happen to their homes or whether they will receive state compensation. Meanwhile, there has been a lack of meaningful solutions at the government and local levels. 

If people affected by the earthquake do not have relatives or acquaintances of influential officials or cannot pay bribes to officials in municipalities and public safety committees, owners of damaged properties are afraid to ask about their rights. This is due to the security-focused nature of the Syrian state, which handles many day-to-day issues that impact people’s lives with secrecy. Such secrecy extends to data, statistics, zoning plans and detailed government plans. In addition, the fact that many people from the coastal region are affiliated with the security and military apparatuses means that they are used to carrying out orders, and public unaccountability has become the norm. 

Speaking with The Syria Report, one resident impacted by the quake described the situation in the public hallways and offices of the Lattakia governorate as a “black hole”. There, information is not transparent, and people do not receive clear answers to questions about their rights. Notably, specific topics are considered taboo and are prohibited. Nobody knows the exact reasons for these informational red lines, who set them, or whether they are simply baseless rumours. Without clear answers or information, most residents conduct their affairs based on hearsay, which eventually snowballs and can include elements of conspiracy theories. 

For example, at one point, discussion of reinforcement permits became banned. In response, residents exchanged rumours about the possibility of the state providing partial compensation for the costs of reinforcing buildings cracked by the earthquake, according to secret, undisclosed lists of recipients. Furthermore, it has become impossible to ask municipalities about evacuating buildings at risk of collapse or sealing them with red wax. Questions about the end destination of building debris are also off-limits. Currently, people are afraid of asking about temporary prefabricated housing, which countries such as China and the UAE have pledged to help provide. This includes questions about the sites for such housing and potential beneficiaries. Residents have discussed that some prefabricated homes arrived in Lattakia but were afraid to ask municipal employees about this. Some rumours even say there are secret lists of housing recipients that do not include everyone affected by the earthquake. 

Abu Ali owns a two-storey building in the Lattakia countryside that partially collapsed due to the earthquake. He decided to rent a home in Homs and move his family there, fearing the building could collapse in the quake aftershocks. During that period, Abu Ali repeatedly visited his municipality and the Lattakia governorate to see what could be done, i.e. whether there was an entity tasked with reinforcing buildings or whether he would be compensated with alternative housing. He didn’t receive any definitive answers. Instead, his valid questions only raised suspicion and annoyance among the employees he interacted with. Abu Ali sold his car and some agricultural land three months after the earthquake. He moved with his family to a Gulf country. He said he had already endured ten years of war in the hopes of it ending and the situation improving. But after the earthquake, he said it was clear that the state would fail to manage any crisis, even natural disasters. 

Sawsan’s house in a rural Lattakia village partially collapsed in the quake and became uninhabitable. She and her family moved to her mother’s house next door. It wasn’t until three months had passed since the earthquake that a structural safety committee arrived in the village to assess the damage. Sawsan asked the committee members if there was a government plan to compensate earthquake-affected residents with alternative housing and how she could obtain such housing. One of the committee’s engineers responded that they had no information. She fears asking such questions to the Lattakia governorate, feeling that the doors of state institutions are closed off to people like her. 

Mohammad is a financially well-off man who owns an old house in Lattakia. A consulting engineer whom Mohammad hired at his own expense after the earthquake advised that the house was no longer habitable. Mohammad and his family left the house and rented a home in the Lattakia countryside, fearing returning to the damaged building would be dangerous. Meanwhile, the governorate refused to grant Mohammad a permit to reinforce his home and barred him from reinforcing it without a permit. Instead, Mohammad decided to reinforce the back of the building without a licence because it is not visible from the street, so the structural safety committees could not monitor it. His attempts to obtain a legal reinforcement permit for the front of the building were unsuccessful. He said the state employees have been unpredictable and make decisions that do not benefit people, leaving them vulnerable to various risks. According to Mohammad, residents have been left to their own devices to face the earthquake aftermath, as well as an authoritarian government that does not care about them. The governorate often issues contradictory decisions, sometimes facilitating reinforcement permits or restricting them without good reason.  

Samer and his family live in Lattakia. Their entire building showed evident cracks from the earthquake. When Samer wanted to submit a request to the municipality for inspection and evaluation of whether the building was safely habitable, other building residents barred him from doing so, fearing involvement with municipal bureaucracy and the safety committees. Samer’s neighbours worried that if the building underwent inspection, the municipality could force them to evacuate their homes or that they might have to reinforce the structure at their own expense. 

Riyad and Bahaa, two brothers, also found cracks in their building, where they live in adjacent apartments. All of the building residents evacuated to nearby shelter centres. The municipality still has not inspected their building, and the brothers have nowhere to live. So they decided to return to their apartments, despite the risk of the building collapsing. Bahaa says living in a dangerous home is better than waiting in uncertainty at a shelter centre. 

Finally, Shaymaa is from Lattakia, where the building she and her family live in collapsed, killing some family members. Shaymaa is currently staying with remaining family members scattered across relatives’ homes. She heard recently that China would provide prefabricated alternative housing to earthquake-affected Lattakia residents but later heard from a relative that the homes were not meant for families. Instead, her relative told her the homes would be small and go to individuals. Shaymaa is afraid of asking the governorate for more information and says no officials have informed her about any potential alternative housing.

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-05-30 19:24:192023-05-30 19:24:19Lattakia Residents Face Uncertainty After Earthquake

National Action Plan and Official Earthquake Response in Regime-Held Territory

16-05-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

Updated on May 29, 2023: We corrected the date of the announcement of the government plan to February 25, from April 25 in the original version.

On February 25, the Syrian government announced the so-called “National Action Plan for Dealing with Earthquake Aftermath – People First,” which addresses the impacts of the February 06 earthquake and restores buildings to their pre-earthquake condition. 

According to the announcement, the government started implementing this plan immediately after the quake and will complete it in 2025. The Higher Relief Committee, chaired by the Minister of Local Administration and including ministries and governmental and non-governmental bodies, leads the plan and oversees its execution.

The plan addresses the earthquake’s aftermath and sets objectives and outcomes that the government must achieve. It also establishes performance and impact indicators as well as a timeline. However, though the plan is filled with promises, it lacks efficient implementation mechanisms, funding monitoring, and clear funding sources. 

The most significant issue in the plan is its conflation of the effects of war and the earthquake. The plan’s approach to these impacts is limited to formally zoned areas. It assumes that the solution in non-zoned areas is simply re-zoning by demolition and reconstruction. The plan does not mention preserving rights or dealing with absent property owners.

The plan is divided into four stages: the first stage is emergency response, aimed at meeting basic humanitarian needs immediately after the disaster. This includes technical inspections of damaged buildings and paying rent compensation for those wishing to rent homes temporarily. The first stage is presumed to have ended, but it remains to be seen if the government actually met its objectives.

The plan’s second stage is for recovery and rehabilitation, which involves assisting affected communities in returning to their everyday lives. Syria is currently presumed to be in this phase, which includes removing debris from buildings destroyed during the earthquake, with a completion date by December 2023. It is unclear how buildings destroyed by the quake will be distinguished from those damaged during the war, given an official inclination to blur the two to increase the count of earthquake-damaged buildings. This second stage also includes facilitating the process of obtaining legal documentation for those affected by the quake, ensuring their legal rights and statuses are settled. It also involves assistance for owners of private properties in zoned areas that were affected to rebuild collapsed or at risk of collapsing buildings and repair cracked ones.

Addressing quake damages in informal settlements has been deferred to the third stage of the action plan, which has not yet begun. This stage involves reconstructing and zoning informal settlements and improving the urban environment to make it better than before the earthquake and war. This means rebuilding the earthquake-damaged informal settlements by creating alternate zoned areas under the purview of the Ministry of Public Works and Housing and the Ministry of Local Administration.

The fourth stage provides an enabling environment to systematically deal with the earthquake’s aftermath so that the government bases its decisions on accurate data.

Ambiguities aside, authorities in Damascus continue to fall short in dealing with the effects of the earthquake. The legislative response to the earthquake has only addressed the destruction of real estate properties from a financial perspective. This includes Legislative Decree No. 7 of 2023, which establishes the National Fund to support those affected by the earthquake, aiming to provide financial assistance and help them overcome physical, material or moral damage. While waiting for its executive instructions to be issued, it remains unclear whether Decree No. 7 will provide any compensation for damages to homes and real estate properties.

Similarly, Legislative Decree No. 3 of 2023 granted those affected by the earthquake certain tax exemptions, some of which relate to their wholly or partially demolished properties. The decree enabled them to access loans to repair their damaged properties. Neither Decree No. 3 of 2023 nor its executive instructions mentioned financial compensation for repairing affected properties, rent allowances for those who lost their homes or any commitment to provide alternative housing, even if not free of charge. For someone to benefit from the tax exemptions included in Decree No. 3, a specialised committee must first identify those affected by the earthquake in each afflicted governorate. The affected individuals must submit their official documents to the committee, a police report confirming damage to their properties, and a record from the public safety committee identifying the nature of the damage. According to these conditions, owners of unlicensed buildings not formally registered in the Land Registry may not receive compensation or tax exemption.

Notably, about three months after the earthquake, the General Directorate of Cadastral Affairs has yet to issue instructions or decisions to address the widespread destruction of real estate properties in government-controlled areas. The Syrian legislative system does not contain any law related to real estate damaged by natural disasters. Previous laws addressing real estate issues have needed a more serious approach to housing, land, and property rights for those affected by natural disasters or wars. In all cases, these laws distinguished between homes built with permits and those without and between informal settlements and zoned areas.

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-05-16 17:14:242023-05-31 01:42:23National Action Plan and Official Earthquake Response in Regime-Held Territory

How are Land Registries in Opposition-Held Areas Responding to the Earthquake?

09-05-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

The February 06 earthquake has made matters more difficult for authorities responsible for managing land registries in opposition-controlled areas of northwestern Syria. Nevertheless, these authorities have not issued any instructions or laws to address the quake’s impacts amid Syria’s lack of legislative framework addressing the properties affected by natural disasters or wars.

The earthquake damage only adds to property rights threats in opposition-controlled areas that have been subjected to bombing over the past few years and suffer from issues related to documenting property ownership, urban planning, and informal housing. As a result, the authorities responsible for managing property interests in these areas appear incapable of documenting and protecting property rights impacted by the quake.

In Syria, the Directorate of Cadastral Affairs is the official body responsible for documenting property ownership and emergency changes to properties. No document related to properties acquires definitive proof unless registered in these records. 

In opposition-controlled areas in northwestern Syria, there are many administrations of this kind, including the Directorate of Cadastral Affairs in Idlib, part of the Hay’at-Tahrir Al-Sham-affiliated Syrian Salvation Government (SSG). Meanwhile, areas under the control of the Turkish-backed Syrian Interim Government (SIG) appear more fragmented, with each cadastral affairs department reporting to the local council of its city or town, e.g. the Cadastral Affairs Department in Azaz, the Directorate of Cadastral Affairs in the city of Al-Bab, and the Land Registry in Afrin.

SSG-controlled areas

The Directorate of Cadastral Affairs in Idlib has not issued any post-earthquake instructions. A source within the directorate told The Syria Report that nobody asked them to do anything. They explained that the procedures followed by the directorate for collapsed properties are as follows: if a property is listed in the Land Registry and is subdivided and the building has been destroyed or demolished, the boundaries of the land on which the property was built can be accurately redefined based on the records. A detailed plan can also be provided for the building as it was before it was destroyed.

The directorate carries out this work at the request of property owners, especially if disputes arise. However, if the property in question is unauthorised, unregistered, and not subdivided within the Directorate of Cadastral Affairs, it is registered as undeveloped land or land prepared for construction. Therefore, the directorate cannot do anything in the event of an earthquake or other disaster.

This situation is not new in Syria and applies to informal housing areas that have been extensively destroyed during the conflict or demolished by the regime. This has resulted in the loss of rights for the owners of these homes, which existed in reality but were not documented in the property records.

Sources told The Syria Report that the SSG’s Ministry of Local Administration and Services dealt with the earthquake’s aftermath but that their approach focused solely on helping those affected. An informed source within the ministry said they did not issue any new decisions or instructions apart from setting up committees to assess the earthquake damage immediately after the fact.

The resource-limited ministry attempted to help those affected by the earthquake by directing humanitarian organisations operating in Idlib towards repairing damaged homes. The ministry coordinated with these organisations and provided them with information about the damaged buildings, their conditions, and needs, whether for demolition, reinforcement or repair. The earthquake damage assessment committees prepared the report. According to a source in one of the organisations, the ministry asked organisations to prioritise repairing the damaged buildings.

For example, Shafaq, a Syrian NGO registered in Turkey since 2013, received the ministry’s approval to work on repairing homes in the town of Maarat Misrin. The ministry provided the organisation with a list of 50 buildings damaged by the quake needing repair and asked them to continue coordinating with the local council in Maarrat Misrin regarding the buildings whose owners had not yet requested an inspection by the committees. The same applies to organisations working in Salqin, Armanaz and other areas under SSG control.

SIG-controlled areas

The situation in areas controlled by the SIG has been similar in regard to how cadastral affairs departments and directorates dealt with the quake aftermath. 

However, it is worth noting that one initiative in the Jandares area of rural Afrin aimed to preserve property rights. Jandares was the area most affected by the earthquake, resulting in the collapse and removal of many buildings and raising concerns about property rights. Therefore, the land registry in Azaz collaborated and met with the Next Day organisation, an NGO concerned with housing, land and property rights, to form a survey committee to determine the locations and boundaries of the destroyed buildings in Jandares, similar to delimitation and census work.

There is an ongoing crisis in addressing property issues in Afrin due to several main factors. Firstly, the property database before 2011 in Afrin exists only within Aleppo’s main cadastral affairs directorate. Second, many property documents left behind by the majority-Kurdish authorities’ land registry during their control of the area between 2012-2018 mostly related to unauthorised construction. Third, significant informal urban expansion has occurred recently, particularly after the opposition took control in 2021.

The Free Engineers Union, Ministry of Local Administration and Services and local councils have all dealt with the quake aftermath in SIG areas. Committees are formed in cooperation with these entities to inspect damaged buildings, assess their technical condition, and determine their needs. However, due to limited resources, local humanitarian organisations bore the burden of funding.

For example, on February 19, a memorandum of understanding was signed between the Engineers Union and Mercy Without Borders, an NGO established in 2012 and registered in Turkey. They launched a comprehensive survey project for facilities and buildings to assess earthquake damage in affected areas in northern Syria. Under this memorandum, the organisation provided the necessary equipment and logistical services for the assessment process and secured wages for the assessment teams in Azaz and Afrin.

In Jandares, the Comprehensive Engineering Survey Project Management for Facilities and Buildings, the Public Safety Committee of the Free Syrian Engineers Union, the Presidency of the Local Council in Jandares city, and engineers from the local council Service Office agreed on the survey, evaluation and supervision of the debris removal from damaged buildings. This process then began in early March, following the survey results.

Also in March, the Ministry of Local Administration and Services formed the Central Committee for Damage Assessment and Surveying in coordination with the Free Engineers Union; the Support Coordination Unit; representatives of the Free Aleppo Governorate Council; local councils in Jandares, Afrin, Azaz, and Suoran; the Syrian Civil Defence, or White Helmets; the Stability Support Unit; the Free Aleppo Lawyers Union; and the Free Aleppo University. These groups decided to form subcommittees in areas affected by the earthquake under the supervision of the SIG to carry out a comprehensive assessment of the earthquake damage, submit proposals and implement them all while preserving housing, land, and property rights.

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-05-09 14:02:222023-05-17 00:17:05How are Land Registries in Opposition-Held Areas Responding to the Earthquake?

Public Safety Committees in Lattakia: Chaos, Corruption, Nepotism

25-04-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

Two months after the February 06 earthquake, the public safety committees in the Lattakia governorate do not appear to be performing their duties effectively. Affected residents have accused the committees of neglecting to inspect damaged buildings, disorganisation, and corruption.

Facing heavy pressure to inspect damaged buildings right after the earthquake, people soon turned to any influential relatives they had in the state, security agencies and the military or resorted to bribing officials to pressure the committees and direct them to inspect their homes early on. 

According to a local correspondent for The Syria Report, the earthquake damaged a recently constructed four-storey building in the Project No. 10 area in Lattakia. After a long wait, building residents lost hope that the committees would inspect it. Fearing the possibility of aftershocks worsening the damage, residents decided to hire a consulting engineer from the Engineers’ Syndicate to assess the damage at their own expense. The engineer advised the building residents to reinforce one cracked central column, which they did promptly. Residents split the cost of this work, with each flat paying SYP 2 million. After they finished, they learned that a committee was on its way to inspect the building. At this point, the residents asked for help from a high-ranking security official to intervene and prevent the committee from inspecting the building.

When the committees inspect damaged buildings, they are meant to classify them into three main categories: slightly damaged, severely damaged, and in need of reinforcement, or at risk of collapse and in need of demolition. Slightly damaged buildings pose no danger to residents and can be repaired without a permit or an engineering study. However, the committee must provide a descriptive report for severely damaged buildings. The relevant local administrative unit then requests another committee, composed of experienced engineers from the Engineers’ Syndicate, to conduct a study for reinforcement. Based on that study, the administrative unit grants a permit for reinforcing the building. Finally, for buildings at risk of collapse that the committees deem necessary to demolish, they seal their entrances with red wax, evacuate the residents and prohibit them from returning home. 

Ward lives in a fourth-storey flat in a building in the Project No. 7 area of Lattakia. The earthquake cracked a main column in his building. Residents waited for the safety committees to inspect the building to no avail. Ward visited the Lattakia governorate building on several different days, submitting official requests for inspection more than once and to more than one department. When he lost hope of receiving a response, Ward paid a bribe of SYP 300,000 to one of the committee members, obtaining a report stating that the building was only slightly damaged. The report was issued without any actual inspection of the building. Based on the report, residents paid themselves for reinforcement work. According to Ward, no one visited the building to inspect it, neither from the committees, the Syndicate, nor the governorate, and no one questioned them about the reinforcement work they carried out.

Meanwhile, the building where Marwa lives with her husband in rural Lattakia was damaged in the quake. A public safety committee inspected the building and found it severely damaged and needing reinforcement. However, the committee asked the couple to refrain from reinforcing it themselves but to wait for the municipality to refer the building to an engineering expertise committee to study the best reinforcement method and obtain a permit. However, Marwa and her husband went to an engineer they know who works on one of the committees to change the report and re-classify the building as only slightly damaged. As a result, they could reinforce the structure without waiting for the engineering expertise committee.

Things were no better in cases where the committees inspected damaged buildings, categorised them as needing minor reinforcement, but then took no clear subsequent actions, leaving the residents confused. For example, Salma, a widow and mother of a special needs child, lives in a damaged house in rural Lattakia. A committee of municipal engineers visited her home, saw the cracks and deemed the house safe for her to remain during reinforcement work. According to a committee member, the house would be safe if there are no future earthquakes. However, for Salma, the repair process is prohibitively expensive. Meanwhile, committee members said neither the municipality nor any other official body would do the reinforcement work. Though there is a chance Salma could be partially compensated if she pays for the reinforcement herself, the compensation mechanism has not been clarified. 

Rizq owns several apartments within a building in an informal neighbourhood of Lattakia. Cracks appeared in several parts of the building after the quake. So he turned to engineer friends and decided to reinforce the building himself at his own expense. During the reinforcement work, one of the governorate committees tried to intervene and stop him. However, Rizq brandished a personal weapon at the committee members and threatened them not to approach.

In another case, the third and top storey of a building owned by retired military general Abu Haidar in a rural Lattakia village partially collapsed. Cracks also appeared on the remaining floors. Abu Haidar hired an engineer and a work crew from Damascus that reinforced the building and rebuilt the collapsed part within a week of the earthquake. The village municipality did not intervene in Abu Haidar’s case. Still, it prevented other residents who didn’t have such connections from repairing their properties without permission.

Meanwhile, in Lattaka city, Wafaa owns an apartment in a building that the committees sealed with red wax and classified as at risk of collapse and need of demolition. After losing hope of receiving any compensation or alternative housing, the building residents decided to reinforce the building out of pocket and paid SYP 3 million to bribe the committee to change the building’s classification to damaged and requiring reinforcement in their report,  the committee agreed to the change. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-04-25 18:36:392023-05-04 08:04:07Public Safety Committees in Lattakia: Chaos, Corruption, Nepotism

Explained: Earthquake Loans

25-04-2023/in Analysis & Features, HLP /by Rand Shamaa

With no comprehensive plan in place to rebuild after the February 06 earthquake, the Syrian government’s approach has focused on providing tax exemptions for those affected and facilitating access to loans so they can fund repairs and reinforcement work. 

These exemptions and promises of loans are no substitute for total or partial reconstruction and rehabilitation of quake-damaged homes. Instead, this method of assistance indicates the inability of the Syrian state to compensate impacted residents with permanent alternative housing and its evasion of responsibilities toward their rights to housing, land and property. Granting loans, even if they are interest-free, means turning the matter of repair and reinforcement into a personal issue with costs borne by the owners of the damaged homes.

Support loan

On February 17, Syria’s Al-Wataniya Microfinance Bank announced the Sanad, or “support,” loan dedicated to repairing and rehabilitating earthquake-damaged homes in Aleppo, Lattakia and Hama governorate. The loans would have a ceiling of up to SYP 18 million interest-free, with a repayment period of six years. In 2011, the Syria Trust for Development, the Syrian Computer Society, and the Small and Medium Projects Development Agency jointly established Al-Wataniya Microfinance Bank.

The bank allocated SYP 10 billion for these loans, with an average of SYP 10 million per loan, aiming to cover expenses for 1,000 damaged homes. For the loans, the bank required a matrix of different types of collateral that can be combined in case one item is insufficient, such as proof of income, guarantees of two individuals, or mortgage of a car, agricultural land, house, gold or insurance policies.

Bank CEO Munir Haroun told the semi-official Al-Watan newspaper on February 19 that borrowers need to obtain a structural safety report for the building that will undergo repairs. He added that the loan would not exclude residents of informal settlements. According to Haroun, the bank will disburse the loans in instalments and appoint committees to assess the quake damage to estimate the size of the initial instalments and conduct subsequent inspections on the progress of repairs. He explained that, for example, an income of SYP 100,000 can obtain a loan of SYP 1.5 million, with a monthly instalment of SYP 35,000. If the applicant is a private sector employee earning SYP 500,000, they can get a loan of up to SYP 10 million. As a merchant with a commercial register and a monthly income of SYP 2 million, they can obtain the maximum loan amount.

On March 5, a banking expert and consultant, Amer Shahda, told Al-Watan that those who actually need this loan could not obtain it, describing the loans as “incapable of fulfilling their tasks” and unsuitable for citizens’ living conditions and the current inflation. Furthermore, he explained that the value of the loan, with a ceiling of SYP 18 million to be repaid over six years, means that the monthly repayment instalment amounts to SYP 250,000, which, in comparison to the incomes of those impacted by the quake, shows they will be unable to pay it. 

Decree No. 3

Legislative Decree No. 3 of 2023 granted people affected by the earthquake certain tax exemptions, some of which relate to totally or partially demolished real estate. The decree also stipulated granting easements in paying outstanding loan instalments and obtaining new loans from public banks for those impacted properties.

The decree allowed public banks to grant interest-free loans with a ceiling of SYP 200 million to those impacted by the quake who wish to fully or partially rebuild or fully or partially rehabilitate their properties. They would have ten years to repay such loans, while repayment of the first instalment is due three years after granting the loan. The state treasury bears the interest and commissions resulting from granting these loans.

Meanwhile, Article 13 of the decree’s executive instructions, issued by the Ministry of Finance in early April, allowed public banks to postpone loan instalments due from affected clients, and collection of repayments would resume on April 1, 2024. Due to this postponement, no contractual interest, delay interest, delay fines or fees shall be added. The postponement applies to all types of loans and facilities previously granted by public banks to those affected by the quake. Meanwhile, Article 14 granted those affected the right to obtain loans from public banks for restoration, rehabilitation or reconstruction, with the amount for such loans determined according to the purpose of the loan, the donor bank’s policies, and the procedures for estimating the value of the funds required. The loan is granted on a case-by-case basis for each independent piece of real estate that faced damage, including facilities, shops, houses, or other buildings. They may be fully damaged, partially damaged or cracked and need reinforcement work. 

Applicants may not finance a single piece of real estate more than once, whether from the same bank or another, taking into account the priority in granting loans to those applying for the first time. Loans granted according to this measure are exempt from the financial solvency requirement set out in the banking operations regulations without prejudice to the banks’ right to recover the necessary collateral. While each bank applies interest rates to these granted loans, ensuring coverage of the minimum borrowing cost, the state’s public treasury bears the contractual interests and commissions resulting from granting these loans.

At the same time, upon issuance of the decree’s executive instructions, a decision was issued by the Central Bank’s Credit and Monetary Council stipulating that deferral of loan instalments due is not considered a restructuring or rescheduling process for banks, according to a report published April 03 by state-run newspaper Tishreen. This is all while preserving the internal credit rating and the level at which the client was classified within this system, and the provisions withheld against them regardless of the instalment deferral.

Article 2 of the Credit and Monetary Council’s decision exempted beneficiaries from repaying the amounts due on inquiry request operations. In return, the bank’s board of directors or general management is responsible for estimating the value of the loan to the affected party based on the expertise report issued by the committee formed under Decree No. 3. Interest rates applicable to each bank will be applied to the loans granted under this decree, taking into account the executive instructions of the decree, particularly concerning the state’s public treasury bearing the contractual interests and commissions. In addition, public banks must consider the loan duration granted to each beneficiary, plus the due date of the first instalment, when calculating the total contractual interests and commissions resulting from granting these loans. Regarding collateral, the decision expressly confirms the application of the current operational systems adopted by public banks to the accepted guarantees for loans granted under Decree No. 3.

Under the decree’s executive instructions, committees will be formed to identify those impacted by the earthquake in each affected governorate. ​​Any affected parties must submit their official documents to these committees, a police report confirming the damage to their properties, and an accredited structural safety committee report from their governorate. The committee then prepares minutes of its work in the completed areas sequentially. After that, lists with the names of the affected persons are issued by the governor’s decision.

The state-run newspaper Al-Baath reported on April 04 that a governor chairs each committee and includes the chairperson of the governorate council, heads of the administrative units in the affected areas, the finance director and service institutions such as water, electricity, telecoms, technical services and real estate services, the head of the Engineers’ Union branch, a representative of the Syria Trust for Development, and the local area representative of the affected region.

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-04-25 18:31:342023-04-25 21:56:56Explained: Earthquake Loans

Explained: Earthquake Insurance

11-04-2023/in Analysis & Features, HLP /by Rand Shamaa

Since the February 6 earthquake, Syrian officials have discussed the need for an insurance policy for natural disasters. The idea for such a policy developed rapidly and may soon be put on the market. 

Home insurance policies are considered essential to protecting properties from various risks, such as fires, theft and leakages. However, insurance specifically for earthquakes requires a separate policy in regions that often experience tremors. Such insurance could prove useful if a home collapses, even if most earthquake insurance policies contain many exceptions, making them useless in some cases of partial collapse or damage to unreported furnishings. 

Syria’s insurance market is still relatively small. The only mandatory insurance policy in place is for third-party car insurance, covering all types of vehicles. Some insurance companies have also offered policies for homes, offices, and private companies to protect them and their contents from certain risks, especially fires and theft. However, these policies are not yet widespread, especially for homes. 

The Syrian government’s enthusiasm for bringing forth an earthquake insurance policy has come as official talk of establishing a national disaster management authority or fund waned. On April 03, Qassioun newspaper, the mouthpiece of the People’s Will Party, reported that the new insurance project would solidify government irresponsibility towards people impacted by potential future disasters and be biassed toward the owners of the companies. 

On February 14, Ibrahim Al-Adi, an economics professor at Damascus University, told the state-owned Al-Baath newspaper that mandatory home and building insurance could lighten repair costs for people during natural disasters. However, he added that the mandatory insurance should only be for new homes and buildings, as well as bridges, roads, and other large structures, and should be a requirement for obtaining a construction permit. Mr Al-Adi also suggested that the insurance money should be within state-affiliated insurance companies. 

On March 08, the state-owned Tishreen newspaper published an article in which the manager of the Syrian Insurance Supervisory Commission confirmed that a month after the February 06 earthquake, the state-owned Syrian Insurance Company and private insurance companies were expected to pay no more than SYP 2 billion in compensation after inspecting earthquake-related damage. This low compensation to quake-affected policyholders is due to low coverage for natural disasters, according to the manager of the commission.

The Syrian Insurance Supervisory Commission, headed by the Minister of Finance, is the body that regulates Syria’s insurance and reinsurance sector. Syria has 12 private insurance companies, one public company (the Syrian Insurance Company) and one reinsurance company, the Arab Union Reinsurance Company. All these companies are part of the Syrian Insurance Federation. 

Insurance expert George Ashqar told Tishreen on March 08 that the government’s natural disaster insurance initiative is essentially a call to share the costs of future disasters. He added that this type of insurance has specific characteristics and requires certain conditions and regulations to be in place before being sold. The most important of these conditions is that buildings considered for insurance must be earthquake resistant. This condition must be confirmed by an official body that issues a document proving the structural resistance of any building in question. 

Mr Ashqar added that if the government is looking to provide compensation and rebuild and restore buildings destroyed by natural disasters, insurance companies should bear some responsibility by selling policies that cover such risks at prices that must undergo long-term study. However, because the potential damages from natural disasters are enormous and costly, insurance companies cannot bear the full risks. As such, they must forge ties with reinsurance companies to help bear a part of the risk with them, Mr Ashqar added. Reinsurance is insurance that one insurance company buys from another to protect itself from the risks incurred by large compensation claims. 

But the Syrian government appears to be rushing to introduce this new policy. A technical committee from the Syrian Insurance Federation has already put together a study on the new insurance policy and made several proposals about the value of instalments and the maximum compensation ceiling.

According to the semi-official Al-Watan newspaper, on March 28, the Ministry of Finance and the Insurance Supervisory Commission discussed the technical committee’s proposals, including the implementation mechanism, tools and statistics, sources of information and data, and the difficulties such a programme might face, mainly a lack of options for foreign reinsurance. Al-Watan did not clarify the reason for this lack of options, but it appears to be related to sanctions. In addition, foreign reinsurance companies will not accept financial transactions in Syrian pounds, while Syrian insurance companies will receive the value of insurance policies in Syrian pounds.

On March 29, Ammar Nasser Agha, dean of the Faculty of Economics at Damascus University, told Al-Watan that Syrian insurance companies could not bear the risks of earthquake damages. He added that an earthquake insurance group should be established. Here, insurance funds for homes could be collected and a portion of it given to local reinsurance companies, which would provide a portion of the money to foreign companies for reinsurance. The insurance money can then be invested over the medium and long term, with the investment going toward assets that can be quickly liquidated in the event of an earthquake. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-04-11 21:44:542023-05-04 08:10:32Explained: Earthquake Insurance

Jandares Two Months on from the Earthquake

11-04-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

Over two months after the February 06 earthquake, the town of Jandares still suffers the impacts of the damage. The town is located in the Afrin region of the Aleppo governorate which is under the control of the Syrian Interim Government (SIG).

The quake virtually destroyed Jandares. It killed around 800 residents, destroyed 278 buildings, and damaged 1,100 buildings. The owners of these destroyed and damaged homes still live across four main shelter centres near the town and in small camps inside Jandares. 

Most original residents of Jandares are Kurds, and in 2012 the majority-Kurdish People’s Protection Units took control of the town. Then in 2018, Turkish-backed opposition factions seized Jandares in Operation Olive Branch, displacing many original residents. Meanwhile, many people forcibly displaced by regime forces from other parts of Syria formerly controlled by the opposition, namely Rural Damascus, Homs, and Hama, arrived and settled in Jandares. According to local council estimates, the town’s population in 2022 was around 115,000 people. 

Immediately after the earthquake, the Aleppo branch of the Free Syrian Engineers’ Syndicate formed comprehensive survey committees (Earthquake Damage Assessment Committees) to conduct field surveys on the 1,100 affected buildings in Jandares. In mid-March, these committees completed their work. They classified the buildings into three categories according to their level of damage: slight, moderate and severe. There were 45 severely damaged buildings. 

Afterwards, Jandares Local Council requested a central public safety committee, consisting of nine syndicate engineers, to inspect the severely damaged buildings and issue a final recommendation for either their removal or reinforcement. The committee decided to completely demolish most of these 45 buildings or demolish parts of them and reinforce the remaining sections.

It should be noted that the Engineers’ Syndicate signed a memorandum of understanding on February 19, 2023, with the non-governmental organisation Mercy Without Limits, which was founded in 2012 and licensed in Turkey. According to the memorandum, the organisation provides equipment, pays for building inspections, covers transportation costs and compensates the engineers.

The survey committees and the Central Safety Committee handed their results to the local council, which is now responsible for implementation. The local council has tasked its demolition and removal committee with issuing a final decision regarding the damaged buildings. Then, on April 06, the local council published a list of ten damaged buildings to destroy and gave their owners a three-day deadline to object. It is not yet clear what the legal mechanisms are in case any of the building owners object. Still, at the time of writing, the council has yet to receive any objections. Therefore, after the three-day deadline ends, the demolition and removal committee will knock down those buildings and remove their rubble. 

In the next stage, the Central Safety Committee will identify moderately damaged buildings requiring reinforcement. It may then decide to reinforce or demolish some buildings, as some moderate-risk buildings have suffered further damage with the earthquake aftershocks.

Samir Bouidani, head of the Central Safety Committee in the Aleppo branch of the Free Syrian Engineers’ Syndicate, explained to The Syria Report some of the engineering standards used to determine the safety of local buildings. For example, the committee removed any building that showed a visible slant, even with no cracks. And any decision to reinforce a building depends on the cost not exceeding 50 percent of the cost of its concrete structure. Here, costs are the deciding factor.

According to Mr Bouidani, determining which reinforcement method to use is not the Central Safety Committee’s job, as each building requires its own specialised engineering study. Therefore, the Engineers’ Syndicate, in coordination with the local council and with the consent of the building owners, refer the matter to private engineering offices licensed. It is still unclear whether any governmental or non-governmental organisations will contribute or fund such reinforcement and restoration for buildings that require this work before being inhabited again.

On the other hand, individual restoration projects on slightly damaged houses have taken place in the town, albeit out of the owners’ pockets. Such work includes rebuilding walls using blocks and cement, plastering, repairing windows, doors, and external walls and repairing inner courtyards. This restoration work often does not include any metal or reinforced concrete for columns and beams. These projects pose risks, including masking the harmful effects of the earthquake on the building’s structural mass, which could mean dangers to these buildings in the future.

As for removing the debris, work is still unorganised as there is no legal mechanism to protect the rights of homeowners’ rubble. NGOs are still working to remove debris from Jandares in cooperation with the local council and the Syrian Civil Defence, also known as the White Helmets. On April 04, the Syrian NGO Takaful Al-Sham, registered in Turkey since 2013, launched the Balsam Project to remove debris and rehabilitate several markets and roads within Jandares, according to the “cash for work” principle. However, like other projects launched by non-governmental organisations, Balsam did not clarify that the debris is the last evidence of the owners’ ownership of their collapsed homes or the fate of the original properties and possessions upon which they were built.

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-04-11 21:34:192023-04-12 13:27:23Jandares Two Months on from the Earthquake

Explained: Executive Instructions for Decree No. 3 on Earthquake Victims

11-04-2023/in Analysis & Features, HLP /by Rand Shamaa

In early April, the Ministry of Finance issued executive instructions for Legislative Decree No. 3 of 2023, which grants tax exemptions to people affected by the February 6 earthquake. Some of the exemptions are related to entirely or partially destroyed properties.

Notably, the executive instructions procedurally violate property and housing rights, as they do not provide any mechanism for absentee property owners in affected areas to benefit from the exemptions stipulated in Decree No. 3. This is despite the fact that it could have been possible to allow the relatives of the absentee owners, or their legal representatives, to submit documents or licensing requests on their behalf. Failure to include such a measure prevents absentee property owners, including those forcibly displaced from their homes, those wanted for security reasons, or detainees and missing persons, from benefiting from the decree.

Decree No. 3 included exemptions for damaged properties from some taxes and fees and granted owners temporary exemptions from future taxes. It also eased obtaining loans to do restoration work on damaged properties. The executive instructions were limited to providing wide-scale, detailed explanations for the tax exemptions included in the decree. It detailed the procedures of forming and running the committees tasked with identifying which owners and damaged properties could benefit. 

Article 2 of Decree No. 3 stipulated the formation of a committee to identify those affected by the earthquake in each impacted province. The executive instructions clarified the committee’s tasks: to identify properties numbers in the affected areas, whether they are commercial establishments, homes, or buildings that were completely or partially destroyed; describe the damage or destruction; determine the building’s occupancy status, identify its use (residential or commercial); and list the owners’ names, property documents, occupants’ names, and their legal documents. In other words, the inventory and description committee’s tasks are identifying, counting and describing the impacted properties.

Owners of damaged properties must submit their official documents to the committee, in addition to a police report proving damage to their property and a certified record from the public safety committee operating in that governorate. The committee then prepares a record of its work, and the governor issues lists of the affected property owners via a decision. 

The executive instructions for Decree No. 3 allowed those whose names are not included in these lists to submit applications to their governorate within 90 days. The same committee then reviews these names and can reject them with reason. However, the instructions did not stipulate that people could appeal these rejection decisions before a special independent committee, contrary to the legal procedures followed in a usual appeal process.

Meanwhile, people whose names appear in the lists have until the end of 2024 to submit applications for construction and renovation permits from their local administrative units. Each permit includes information about the property owner, property number, real estate area, accurate work details, and the time needed to complete it. With those items submitted, the applicant can benefit from the exemptions mentioned in Decree No. 3. 

The decree does not exempt people impacted by the earthquake from paying the real estate sales tax stipulated in Real Estate Sales Law No. 15 of 2021. However, it does exempt such taxes if the sales transaction took place before the implementation of Law No. 15. Meaning that an official must document the sales deed before Law No. 15 came into effect. In essence, this stipulation implies that the property owners affected by the February 6 earthquake must submit official documents (such as a property financial clearance certificate issued by the finance department) that were certified before the enforcement of Law No. 15. The owners may instead provide certified copies of the financial records approved by the tax authorities if the documents were lost during the earthquake.

Finally, according to the executive instructions, rental transactions of properties in earthquake-affected areas are exempt from fees usually charged by administrative units under the Financial Law of Administrative Units No. 37 of 2021.

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-04-11 21:20:122023-04-12 11:59:56Explained: Executive Instructions for Decree No. 3 on Earthquake Victims

Structural Safety Committees Inspect Earthquake-Damaged Buildings in Damascus

04-04-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

Recent weeks have seen the Damascus governorate form dozens of structural safety committees to inspect buildings in the capital, which was not really impacted by the February 6 earthquake. 

Immediately after the quake, the governorate set up a WhatsApp number to let residents of Damascus get in touch and report any cracks in their buildings. After receiving these reports, a joint committee would be dispatched to inspect the building for cracks and issue recommendations. The governorate forms these committees with other official entities, so that they include engineers and experts from both sides. For example, there are nine joint committees between the governorate and the University of Damascus Faculty of Engineering; 12 between the governorate and the Higher Institute for Seismic Research; and nine emergency joint committees between the governorate and the Damascus branch of the Syrian Engineers Syndicate. 

In addition, the governorate formed committees consisting of its own engineers and its 16 municipalities, for a general inspection of all buildings in the city’s municipal services directorate. The governorate also formed a committee to oversee any reinforcement work, which would accompany the local engineering committees on an as-need basis.

At the governorate’s request, the Damascus branch of the Syrian Engineers Syndicate formed a 15-person emergency committee headed by their branch president tasked with assessing the technical safety of facilities and buildings. It was also aimed at providing technical support and test construction materials in the syndicate’s laboratory. 

Finally, the General Company for Engineering Studies (GCES), affiliated with the Ministry of Public Works and Housing, formed a committee to inspect government buildings in Damascus for structural safety. 

These committees have inspected a combined 2,300 buildings in the capital based on reports from residents, according to an estimate by the Damascus governor published in the official Tishreen newspaper on March 23.

Sources told The Syria Report that the committees found cracks in the walls of some buildings in the Al-Mazzeh 86 neighbourhood. One of the buildings, which consisted of five storeys, showed cracks in its columns and was temporarily evacuated. However, inspectors allowed residents to return to the building, asking them to fill the cracks with cement and monitor them. If the cracks were to grow, then the committee there would study possible reinforcement of the building. Lastly, they recommended constructing several retaining walls in the area at the governorate’s expense. 

Some committees inspecting homes in Al-Sham Al-Jedida suburb, previously known as Dummar residential suburb, found that some buildings there had sunk several centimetres into the ground. One committee requested that residents of at least one building construct full metal reinforcements around its load-bearing columns, with the engineering study and implementation costs to be paid for by the residents themselves. 

In general, the committees lacked any unified engineering standards and chaos prevailed. Each committee conducted merely visual inspections of the buildings in their areas without using testing equipment or scales. They then classified the buildings according to their structural safety, listing them as either safe and undamaged, as damaged and in need of reinforcement, or, finally, as damaged, at risk of collapse and in need of evacuation and demolition. 

The Syria Report’s sources said the most active committees were those that included members from the Engineers’ Syndicate, as it seeks to regain its engineering role after having been marginalised in recent years by the Construction Contractors’ Syndicate. The Engineers’ Syndicate succeeded in imposing unified standards for the fees of engineering studies, inspections of damaged buildings and facilities, and supervision of reconstruction or reinforcement work. This was apparent in Ministry of Public Works and Housing Decision No. 1698 on February 27, 2023, which approved the Syrian Engineers’ Syndicate Central Council Decision No. 4 — this measure reduced the fees for engineers to check on the status of buildings damaged by the earthquake in the most heavily impacted governorates. However, the syndicate was not able to set clear, unified standards for how to inspect damaged buildings or to undertake restoration and reinforcement work, instead leaving that task to the engineering committees.

Meanwhile, no rights organisations participated in monitoring the work of the committees, nor was there any documentation of the damaged properties as the process lacked legal mechanisms for objecting to the committees’ decisions. Based on the committees’ recommendations, the Damascus governorate demolished some of the buildings that were at risk of collapse, after they underwent inspection. All of these buildings were already at risk before the earthquake and were only further damaged in the disaster, including buildings in the Kafr Sousa and Sarouja neighbourhoods. The governorate offered residents of these buildings the option of moving into temporary shelter centres, but most of them decided instead on moving to other parts of the city at their own expense. 

Sources told The Syria Report that some residents are afraid to report the cracks in their buildings, fearing they could be evacuated and their homes demolished without any hope of compensation, forcing them to live in the shelter centres or in rental homes at their own expense. Other residents in cracked buildings even tried bribing the committees or pressuring them to issue reports saying their homes were structurally sound. Meanwhile, other people feared that influential figures could seize buildings at low prices by pressuring the committees into deeming safe buildings to be at risk of collapse. This lack of legal mechanisms, as well as fears of security pressure, have restricted the work of engineers on the committees, some of whom have consequently tried to avoid making the right decisions, fearing potential consequences. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-04-04 15:53:102023-04-04 15:53:10Structural Safety Committees Inspect Earthquake-Damaged Buildings in Damascus

Syrian Engineers’ Syndicate and the February 6 Earthquake

28-03-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

On February 27, 2023, the Syrian Engineers’ Syndicate Central Council issued Decision No. 4, which reduces the fees levied by engineers to assess the condition of damaged buildings in the governorates most impacted by the February 6 earthquake: Lattakia, Aleppo, Hama and Idlib. That same day, the head of the syndicate approved the decision through his own Decision No. 27, which in turn was approved by the Ministry of Public Works and Housing Decision No. 1698. 

Engineers’ Syndicate Decision No. 4 of 2023

Decision No. 4 intends to provide a unified system for collecting various engineering fees and aims to bring an end to the pricing chaos that accompanied the February 6 quake. Previously, local branches of the syndicate issued separate decisions to determine these fees in earthquake-damaged areas, without referring to the Central Council.

Decision No.4 consists of six paragraphs, the first four of which address lowering the fees  usually charged by engineers for inspecting buildings, conducting engineering studies or supervising restoration works. Paragraph five lays out the financial contributions of the syndicate to engineers’ fees. Finally, paragraph six reaffirms that Engineers’ Syndicate Decision No. 43 of 2022 is the reference text for determining engineering fees, which are referred to in last month’s Decision No. 4 as “applicable fees”. 

Depending on whether the studies and reports are requested by building owners or by the local administrative units the discount offered on engineering fees is either partial or full. For example, if a local administrative unit requests a technical evaluation report for a building, the engineers are required to prepare it for free. When building owners make a request for inspecting and carrying out a study of the condition of their building, engineers will also not charge fees on licensed buildings or facilities that suffered earthquake damage. However, they are entitled to charge up to 50 percent of their usual fees to supervise restoration works.

Engineers’ Syndicate Decision No. 43 of 2022

Usually, the syndicate issues an annual list of fees for engineering work. The current list of applicable fees was published in the syndicate’s 114-page Decision No. 43 of 2022. Consisting of 14 chapters, the decision lists the minimum fees for civil, architectural, electrical, mechanical, chemical, geological, environmental, software and medical engineering work. It also includes the fees for studies and supervision of various types of facilities, as well as for executive and economic feasibility studies, engineering supervision and more. 

Decision No. 43 sets the engineering fees for new construction projects as follows: engineering study fees are 1.5 percent of the cost of construction. This study must in turn be inspected by a consultant engineer whose fee is one-third that of the engineering study — i.e., 0.5 percent of the approved construction cost. The fee for the engineer supervising the implementation of a residential construction project is 2.5 percent of the construction cost. In short, the total fees for study, inspection and supervision come out to 4.5 percent of the construction cost. 

Regarding reinforcement work, Decision No. 43 sets a flat fee of SYP 48,825 for reinforcement studies of each structural element (retaining walls, shear walls, foundations, etc.), provided the amount earned by the engineer to perform the study is no less than SYP 167,400 fee. The inspecting engineer and supervising engineer each receive a sum equal to one-third the studying engineer’s fee. 

Key takeaways from Decision No. 4 of 2023

The decision only applies to governorates that were considered the worst impacted by the February 6 quake, despite some buildings in other governorates like Homs, Rural Damascus and Tartous suffering partial or total collapse in the disaster. This means that owners of damaged buildings in those governorates must pay the full fees incurred, such as those for licensing, studies, inspection and implementation, in addition to any reconstruction costs. 

The syndicate also exempted owners of licensed, destroyed buildings in earthquake-affected governorates from paying some fees if they reconstruct their buildings according to previously approved plans. In other words, the syndicate is exempting them from paying the fees for already-completed engineering studies. Notably, however, this means those buildings are being reconstructed without taking into account the reasons they collapsed, putting them at risk of collapsing yet again if stricken by an earthquake of the same magnitude. The decision also states that the local administrative unit is the entity that may approve modifications to a building plan undergoing reconstruction, albeit without specifying reasons for those modifications. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-03-28 18:06:002023-04-14 14:21:26Syrian Engineers’ Syndicate and the February 6 Earthquake

Calls Grow for Government to Expropriate Absentees’ Properties to Provide Housing for Earthquake-Affected Communities

28-03-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

Calls have circulated in recent days on social media and in some official news outlets calling for the government to seize absentee homeowners’ properties to distribute or lease them to people impacted by the February 6 earthquake. Businesspeople and officials have made these calls and urged the government to seize properties without the consent of the owners. 

They have also demanded the issuance of a new law that would allow the state to expropriate absentee-owned properties, seize all properties unoccupied by their owners or confiscate any homeowners’ additional uninhabited properties. These demands are based on the now-defunct Tenancy Law No. 111 of 1952 (which was repealed by Tenancy Law No. 6 of 2001) as well as Expropriation Law No. 20 of 1983. 

In both cases, these demands appear unrealistic and would violate the property rights of absentees. Syria’s new tenancy law and the expropriation law do not include provisions allowing seizing a property from their owner and giving it to another person for any reason. The recent demands also go against the 2012 constitution, which in Article 15 says that it protects private property rights and only allows expropriation under certain conditions and procedures. 

Tenancy Law No. 111

Tenancy Law No. 111 of 1952 entitled local administrative units’ social affairs departments to lease properties without the owners’ consent. These departments had the task of registering and documenting lease contracts between lessors and renters. Under Law No. 111, they used to operate under the supervision of the judiciary, headed by the relevant governorate’s magistrate. But later, these departments came under the supervision of the governor or relevant local mayor, in accordance with Law No. 187 of 1970. 

Law No. 111 also allowed the social affairs departments to register vacant residential properties for rent, and required owners to register such properties with the social affairs departments within 15 days of their vacancy. Punitive penalties included fines and imprisonment for up to one year for residential building owners and apartment owners who failed to notify authorities of any property vacancies or otherwise violated the law’s provisions – in practice, however, these provisions of the law were rarely implemented. 

Finally, Law No. 111 delegated the task of searching for vacant properties and registering and leasing them (without owners’ consent) to local mukhtars, police officers and social affairs department employees. Under the law, tenants who vacated a home were required to inform their local social affairs department within 15 days.

In 2001, a new tenancy law, Law No. 6, was issued, overriding Law No. 111 of 1952. A number of other tenancy laws followed it, the last of which was Law No. 20 of 2015. In these new laws the social affairs departments in local administrative units no longer had the power to lease properties without their owners’ consent. Law No. 20 grants these departments power only to register and document lease contracts. As a result, lease contracts became enforceable deeds that allowed lessors to turn to the court and evict tenants upon the expiration of the lease. 

In short, using a now-defunct law to justify the takeover of residential properties in order to lease them to earthquake-affected communities is not legally valid. Such a solution would also violate the provisions of the laws currently in force. 

Expropriation Law

Expropriating closed or vacant apartments in order to lease them also violates Expropriation Law No. 20 of 1983. Under this law, expropriation may be done for projects that are for the public benefit, such as roads, barracks, airports, railways, hospitals, schools, agriculture, irrigation, oil, energy, mineral wealth, security and defence. Expropriation of privately owned buildings for purposes of leasing is not on that list of potential projects. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-03-28 17:53:262023-03-28 17:53:26Calls Grow for Government to Expropriate Absentees’ Properties to Provide Housing for Earthquake-Affected Communities

Explained: Decree Grants Tax Exemptions to People Impacted by February 6 Quake

21-03-2023/in Analysis & Features, HLP /by Rand Shamaa

More than a month after the February 06 earthquake, President Bashar Al-Assad issued a decree granting tax exemptions for people impacted by the disaster. Some of the measures listed in Legislative Decree No. 3 of 2023 are related to real estate that was partially or fully damaged in the earthquake, exempting owners from some current taxes and fees and temporarily from future taxes. The decree also eases the process for obtaining loans to restore damaged properties. 

At the same time, the decree did not include financial compensation to repair damaged properties, rental allowances for those who lost their homes, and promises of alternative housing. In short, the decree added nothing new regarding housing, land, and property rights for earthquake-affected communities, instead approaching the disaster from a technical and financial angle. 

In this sense, Decree No. 3 of 2023 is similar in content to the previous Decree No. 13 of 2022. The 2022 measure granted wide-reaching facilities and tax exemptions for properties in old city centres within Aleppo, Homs and Deir-ez-Zor governorates, including historic souks. 

Decree No. 3 of 2023 only extends to people impacted by the February 06 earthquake, and stresses that it does not apply to any other natural disasters. Furthermore, the decree’s scope is limited to the governorates most affected by the quake: Aleppo, Lattakia, Hama and Idlib. Beneficiaries include real estate owners or occupants whose facilities, shops, homes or buildings suffered full or partial collapse or were cracked and need reinforcement. 

For each earthquake-affected governorate, the Minister of Local Administration and Environment is tasked with forming a committee of “relevant entities” to identify the residents impacted by the February 06 disaster. Based on each committee’s findings, governors issue decisions officially identifying their governorate’s impacted residents. 

These identified residents will then be exempted from all taxes, financial fees, local fees and costs, service payments, permit fees and any additional costs imposed for partial or full reconstruction work or rehabilitation of facilities, shops, homes and buildings. In short, the decree granted exemptions for such payments – most importantly fees for reconstruction and rehabilitation permits – until the end of 2024. Anyone who wishes to conduct such work is no longer required to pay such fees during that time. 

Rehabilitation of a building means it can be repaired without the need for demolition or removal. On the other hand, reconstruction means that the building was damaged beyond rehabilitation and needs to be rebuilt or either fully or partially restored. 

The state imposes obligatory taxes on all citizens in order to secure treasury funds, without providing any direct services in exchange. Financial fees, on the other hand, are payments made to benefit the public treasury in exchange for certain services; these include real estate fees. Local fees and costs are those imposed by local councils in exchange for provision of services, such as sanitation. Only those who benefit from the relevant public services pay financial and local fees. 

Finally, service fees are those imposed by public entities or institutions for certain services, such as rubble removal, water and sewage networks. Additional or supplemental charges on service fees can be imposed during reconstruction or rehabilitation work in exchange for supervision from the Engineers Syndicate and employees of the Directorate of Cadastral Affairs’ Surveying Department. 

Article 2 of the decree exempts people impacted by the quake from paying real estate income and building plot taxes, which are annual taxes for real estate and other facilities of all categories, whether fully built or still under construction, and whether for residential, commercial or industrial purposes. In addition, Article 2 exempted earthquake-impacted property owners from the local fees and costs mentioned in Financial Law of Administrative Units No. 37 of 2021. 

Article 6 of the recent decree also cancelled the checking of paying for due taxes and fees prior to March 12, 2023, the date when the decree was issued. Next, Article 7 cancelled the checking of paying for due real estate and building plot income taxes in the earthquake-damaged areas. Cancelling these checking of paying for due taxes and fees means suspending as-yet-unpaid old requests for tax and fee payments on collapsing buildings. As a consequence, the decree suspended payments of some old taxes and fees incurred on damaged properties before its implementation date. 

According to Article 11, the exemptions only extend to people whose facilities, shops, homes or buildings suffered full or partial destruction or were cracked and need reinforcement. This means that safe, undamaged properties are not exempt, even if they are located in earthquake-damaged area, with the exception of real estate and construction plot taxes, which are suspended for all real estate in damaged areas according to Article 7. 

Paragraph B of Article 11 clarified that the tax exemptions and suspensions do not include real estate sales taxes that are subject to Law No. 15 of 2021. Consequently, this means that sales of real estate in earthquake-damaged zones remain subject to real estate sales taxes, though it is unclear why they are not exempt. 

The decree also stated that people impacted by the quake would be granted easements in paying off any loans incurred and obtaining new loans from public banks. Under Article 14, public banks may grant interest-free loans with a SYP200-million ceiling to people hoping to either partially or rebuild following the quake, or those hoping to rehabilitate their properties. 

According to the decree, the loan payback period is ten years, so long as the first payment is made within three years of the date the loan was granted. The state treasury bears any interest and commissions arising from granting the loans. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-03-21 19:22:042023-03-22 13:16:02Explained: Decree Grants Tax Exemptions to People Impacted by February 6 Quake

Post-earthquake Shelter Centres in Lattakia City

15-03-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

In the aftermath of the February 6 earthquake, many survivors whose homes were either partially or fully destroyed sought shelter in dozens of shelter centres set up hastily in Lattakia city. The number of these shelters has decreased in recent days to just 15, with many people returning to their homes after ascertaining their structural safety, according to The Syria Report’s local correspondent. 

Schools

After a building just across from their house collapsed, Munira and her husband, both in their late 60s, moved into a shelter centre set up in a Lattakia city school. According to Munira, all 24 residents of the shelter centre went without any aid for days following the earthquake. She began to develop severe kidney pain due to the extreme cold and from sitting on wooden seats meant for students and had to be transported to a hospital. 

Munira told The Syria Report that most children in the shelter centre developed colds. It wasn’t until the fifth day after the earthquake that volunteer teams from NGOs arrived and handed out meals, mattresses, blankets, medicine and baby formula. 

From the shelter centre, Munira and her husband returned to their home, which structural safety teams hadn’t yet inspected. Though the couple feared aftershocks and the house potentially had some invisible cracks, it was more comfortable for them than the shelter centre. 

The shelters set up in Lattakia city’s school buildings are the worst in terms of services provided to residents. Even before the earthquake, the schools were unclean and faced continuous power cuts, poorly maintained bathrooms and hot water shortages. Initially, shelters were set up in 25 school buildings, where people took refuge after the quake. People stayed in classrooms without blankets, electricity, heating devices, hot water, or working bathrooms. 

In some cases, women faced harassment in the shelters, mainly due to a lack of management supervision. Naila, a woman in her 20s, lives alone. Part of the building collapsed due to the earthquake, so she went with her neighbours to a shelter centre in a nearby school. While there, a young man tried to exploit Naila’s need for housing, repeatedly offering to move her into an apartment where she could live on her own. When she refused, the man made an offer of customary marriage. To escape the situation, Naila went to stay with relatives outside of Lattakia city. 

 

The Municipal Stadium and the Sports City

Said and his family were displaced to Lattakia’s Municipal Stadium when their house partially collapsed in the quake. Because Said is active in a civil society NGO, his family was able to use his connections to obtain an electric heater. He could also find some privacy for his sisters in a separate room. 

Aid organisations assisted in the stadium shelter centre immediately after the earthquake, including three meals daily for residents and medicine for those in need. According to The Syria Report’s local correspondent, the stadium is among the best shelter centres in Lattakia. About 4,000 sought shelter there right after the quake, though only 300 remained at the time of writing. Electricity is available in the stadium, with only two-hour daily cutoffs. 

 

The same goes for the existing shelter centre in Lattakia Sports City, which received many displaced people from Aleppo and the rural parts of the Lattakia governorate throughout the war. The two centres were ideal for communicating with NGOs and government organisations to provide aid.

 

Mosques

Rama, her husband, and her infant son were displaced to a neighbourhood mosque after cracks appeared in their home due to the earthquake. The family of three suffered from a lack of privacy in the shelter centre. Everyone who had fled there lived together in the central part of the mosque with no dividers, which made changing clothes and bathing very difficult, especially for women. 

Food supplies arrived at the mosque in the very first days after the quake but were distributed in an unorganised manner. It wasn’t until six days after the earthquake that aid organisations began paying attention to women’s needs. Nevertheless, residents say that the mosque shelter centres are among the best because they are cleaned regularly and have steady electricity and hot water supplies. The biggest issue in these shelters is the lack of privacy, especially for women. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-03-15 10:31:472023-03-21 20:02:52Post-earthquake Shelter Centres in Lattakia City

Explained: Syrian Law and HLP Rights in Natural Disasters

15-03-2023/in Analysis & Features, HLP /by Rand Shamaa

No law in Syria’s legislative system specifically addresses real estate damaged by natural disasters. Article 24 of the Syrian Constitution, issued as part of Decree No. 94 of 2012, says that the state, alongside the society, bears the burdens resulting from such disasters, without any indication of which laws deal with such events. 

Although some laws mention issues related to real estate damaged by natural disasters, they do not address housing, land, and property rights. In all these cases, the few laws that exist for natural disasters distinguish between licensed buildings and buildings built without construction permits, as well as between informal settlements and zoned areas. 

Syrian Civil Code

Article 817 of Syrian Civil Code No. 84 of 1949 states that the owners may form a union where the real estate is divided into separate apartments or storeys. Under Article 823, if the building is destroyed by a fire or other means, the partners in this union must abide by what the union decides by the majority. 

If the union decides to rebuild, then compensation money due for the damages is allocated. In practice, this means that for licensed buildings in a zoned area, should most owners want to rebuild, then reconstruction is carried out at their expense. Each owner contributes according to their share in the building. The union may also employ compensation money or assistance the state provides for reconstruction. Afterwards, the building is returned to its owners in the same condition it was in beforehand. 

In practice, however, residential building unions like the ones mentioned above have yet to be formed in Syria. Instead, there is Law on Building Occupants’ Organisations and their Administrative Committees No. 55 of 2022, issued to regulate and maintain the commonly used portions of residential buildings and thus enable occupants to settle disputes arising from their use. This law is non-binding, and many buildings do not have such committees. 

If the building cannot be reconstructed, the shareowners may terminate their common ownership of the property and divide it up. First, they must correct the legal property description of the real estate and list it as merely a plot of land slated for construction. In other words, subdivided ownership of the building ceases to exist, and each owner reverts to joint owners of the land itself. In such cases, the owners are entitled to the rubble of their former homes and any monetary compensation or aid as decided by the state.

Law No. 15 of 2008

In cases where Real Estate Development and Investment Law No. 15 of 2008 is applied to an area damaged by a natural disaster, the real estate developer must secure alternative housing for occupants or pay an agreed-upon cash allowance. Recipients must pay for any alternative accommodation they are allocated. This law may include real estate within and outside an existing zoning plan. It also stipulates allocating and selling real estate residential shares within the zoned real estate area to occupants of expropriated homes after the completion of construction work. 

Under Article 14 of this law, real estate development and investment projects aimed at sheltering people impacted by natural disasters are a top priority among other projects.

Law No. 33 of 2008 

For real estate destroyed by natural disasters, Syria’s executive authority may apply Law No. 33 of 2008, which addresses establishing ownership for built properties and parts of unbuilt properties in informal settlements or areas with mass unlicensed construction. This is although the law itself does not mention natural disasters. 

To apply Law No. 33 to real estate destroyed by natural disasters, the properties must have undergone delimitation and census, be recorded in the Land Registry and be connected within one area. According to the law’s executive instructions, the buildings on these properties must also constitute at least 50 percent of the properties’ surface areas. 

This law does not stipulate granting alternative housing or compensation for people impacted by natural disasters, as its scope is limited to simply establishing ownership of properties. Law No. 33 may not apply to a damaged area if another zoning, urbanisation, real estate development or investment law is in force there.

Legislative Decree No. 40 of 2012 

Legislative Decree No. 40 of 2012, which focuses on unlicensed construction, states that if a property within a zoned area built in violation of the building permit has been destroyed, it becomes the owners’ common property. Those owners may request a renewed construction permit per the building codes in place. 

Decree No. 40 does not entitle owners of unlicensed buildings to any rights should their properties collapse. Instead, Article 2 of the law states that if an unlicensed facility is incapable of standing (according to an assessment by that governorate’s public safety committee) then whoever is found responsible should be sentenced to a year to three years imprisonment. Should the building’s collapse cause the death of one or more persons, the penalty increases to at least ten years of hard labour and three times the usual fine. 

Law No. 23 of 2015

Chapter two on Zoning and Urbanisation Law No. 23/2015 can apply to areas impacted by natural disasters such as earthquakes or floods. However, the law leaves it up to the local administrative units in damaged areas to apply zoning measures according to prior zoning plans when implementing approved plans, meaning they are not obliged to rezone areas impacted by natural disasters.

Law No. 23 does allow exemptions from fees and any other local costs and sums related to rebuilding destroyed real estate. At the same time, the law entitles administrative units to deduct parts of these damaged areas free of charge and expropriate areas containing mass unlicensed construction that happen to be located within approved zoning plans. 

The law calls for creating compulsory land readjustment committees tasked with giving rights holders their due shares, either within or near the location of their original property. Rights holders may also be granted plots of land to be commonly owned between them, provided each owner’s share is identified. However, these measures apply only to properties that have been licensed. Law No. 23 states that owners have rights only over the rubble for unlicensed properties within zoned areas or state-owned lands. Administrative entities may choose to sell alternative housing to the owners of unlicensed properties if there is a surplus.  

Law No. 10 of 2018

Law No. 10 of 2018 stipulates that one or more zoned real estate areas may be established within the zoning plans of an administrative unit and was meant to complement Legislative Decree No. 66 of 2012. The 2018 law may be applied only to areas containing unlicensed construction and informal housing destroyed by natural disasters, as it does not stipulate any application in already licensed buildings in zoned areas. 

Article 43 of Law No. 10 states that owners of unlicensed construction only have the right to the rubble of their buildings and the possibility of being allocated alternative housing by the local administrative unit if there is a surplus. However, they must pay for such housing. They may also receive two years of rent allowance. 

Law No. 3 of 2018

Finally, Law No. 3 of 2018, which focuses on removing the rubble of damaged buildings, was issued in response to the destruction Syria faced due to the war. However, the law also includes measures for removing the rubble of buildings destroyed by natural causes such as earthquakes. In either case, it is up to the relevant governor, based on proposals by local administrative units, to determine which damaged areas will undergo rubble removal. 

Law No. 3 does not differentiate between the rubble of buildings in zoned vs unzoned areas. It also does not stipulate what is meant to happen to lands where debris has been removed or when facilities at risk of collapse have been demolished. The law does not clarify whether owners of these properties may construct new buildings, whether they must be compensated or even if the land is expropriated, whether allowance payments or alternative housing must be given to the owner. However, Law No. 3 clearly states that property owners have ownership rights over the rubble of their buildings. 

This law is not limited to only removing building rubble but also includes the possibility of administrative units demolishing damaged buildings and removing debris. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-03-15 10:26:132023-03-21 20:05:18Explained: Syrian Law and HLP Rights in Natural Disasters

Tallying the Damages from the February 6 Earthquake

07-03-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

During a March 2 meeting chaired by the Minister of Local Administration and Environment, Syria’s Higher Relief Committee stated that the earthquake had impacted 414,304 people in Syria. 

The committee added that 4,444 buildings were unsafe for return and could not be reinforced, while 29,751 buildings needed reinforcement work to be safe. There were 30,113 buildings deemed safe but needing maintenance work and 292 buildings that had been demolished to protect public safety. This survey was conducted in coordination with structural safety teams and technical assistance committees. 

During a parliamentary session on February 20, the Minister of Local Administration and Environment said that 199 buildings collapsed during the earthquake.

The affected governorates

It appears from the figures reported by each governorate separately that the number of damaged buildings at risk of collapse is vast and is incommensurate with the number of buildings that collapsed at the moment of the earthquake and that their total is greater than the numbers reported by the Higher Relief Committee. It is also difficult to precisely determine whether all these buildings were damaged by the February 6 earthquake or had suffered previous damages. 

Aleppo

The semi-official Al-Watan newspaper published a report on February 27 about the Higher Relief Committee’s branch in Aleppo governorate, stating that the body had examined 11,277 buildings. Of those, 8,600 were deemed structurally sound, while 2,677 were structurally unsound due to the earthquake. 

In a February 19 press conference, the Aleppo governorate stated that 53 buildings had collapsed due to the earthquake; The Syria Report found that 50 buildings were located in formerly opposition-held parts of east Aleppo city and many were uninhabited and already at risk of collapse. The other three collapsed buildings were old and in poor condition and located in central Aleppo city. No building collapses were recorded in the city’s western neighbourhoods, which remained relatively protected from armed conflict during the war. 

Before the earthquake, most of the buildings that risked falling in Aleppo had previously been damaged by fighting. In November 2022, the Aleppo City Council demolished some of the 1,500 buildings at risk of collapse. These buildings had faced regime bombing damage during the period of opposition control over that part of the city in 2012-2016. 

Lattakia

In a March 2 press conference by the Relief Operations Room in Lattakia governorate, the governor said that 27,641 buildings had been inspected. Some 967 buildings had been completely damaged and could not undergo reinforcement work. 

According to preliminary official figures issued in the first days after the quake, around 50 buildings in the Lattakia governorate collapsed fully and another 50 buildings partially. On February 14, The Syria Report wrote that at least 50 buildings in the governorate had fully collapsed, including at least 16 in Lattakia city alone. 

Hama

According to the Hama branch of the Higher Relief Committee and its operations room, by February 27, the governorate had inspected 38,000 homes and shops. Of those, 2,000 buildings were at risk of collapse and required evacuation. Many buildings were deemed safe but had cracks and needed restoration work. 

These numbers appear quite extensive and don’t match the only four buildings recorded to have collapsed in Hama during the earthquake. Two of those buildings were in Hama city, one of which was uninhabited, while the other two were in the rural part of the governorate. One apparent explanation is that the Hama governorate classified all buildings that failed to meet structural safety standards as buildings that were damaged in the quake. 

Tartous

A source in Tartous governorate told Al-Watan on February 28 that engineering teams had, to date, inspected 4,000 buildings. Of those buildings, 117 were homes that needed to be demolished and 587 needed reinforcement. 

Dozens of old homes had partially collapsed in the area around Al-Qadmous Castle due to the earthquake. Other homes in the main souk of Baniyas city also faced damage. 

 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-03-07 19:09:282023-03-07 19:11:40Tallying the Damages from the February 6 Earthquake

Temporary Housing for Syria’s Earthquake-Impacted Residents

07-03-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

Since the first days following the February 6 earthquake, Syrian officials have issued statements saying they would secure alternative housing for people in regime-held areas whose homes had collapsed completely or were at risk of collapse due to cracks. But as more time has passed, officials have begun using a different term: temporary housing for residents of shelter centres. 

Alternative housing is a loose term that usually refers to non-free housing implemented by the General Housing Establishment (GHE) as part of the country’s social housing programmes. Residents of informal settlements may apply to receive such housing if their homes are expropriated or demolished or if their neighbourhoods are re-zoned. However, Syrian law does not stipulate any rights to alternative housing for those whose homes have been affected by natural disasters. 

While temporary alternative housing or temporary housing, according to official statements, are new terms describing prefabricated housing units that will be transported to earthquake-affected governorates and will apply to people currently staying in shelter centres. A typical unit consists of one or two rooms. 

It remains unclear who will pay for setting up and transporting these units, how they will be distributed, and who will benefit from them. Some official statements have said they welcome foreign aid to fund the construction of housing units and the provision of ready-made ones. Some statements have also been vague and contradictory in terms of where the units will be set up, how many there will be and their prices and costs. Also, it is unclear what the eventual fate of these prefabricated housing units will be, who owns them and whether they will be dismantled at some point in the future. 

The government’s approach appears to have gradually abandoned talk of alternative housing in its long-term sense (as well as any related rights for residents) in favour of focusing on prefabricated housing units to be used as temporary alternatives to the shelter centres. This concept has gradually developed over the past several weeks and appears to both fall in line with the government’s financial capabilities and lighten popular pressure by securing some housing units for affected residents. But this is a medium-term approach and does not solve the problem. 

The Minister of Public Works and Housing told the semi-official Al-Watan newspaper on February 20 that those currently impacted by the earthquake cannot continue to stay in the temporary shelter centres for a long period. The state needs the centres back at some point to use them again for its original services. 

How many prefabricated housing units are there? 

The idea for prefabricated housing units first emerged on February 15, when the Minister of Public Works and Housing called on ministry-affiliated public construction companies to prepare 100 units, which are now now available. The minister also asked these companies’ managers to immediately procure more of the prefabricated housing units and provide them to the government. The public construction companies affiliated with the Ministry of Public Works and Housing are the General Housing Establishment, the General Company for Building and Construction, the General Company for Water Projects, the General Company for Electrical and Communication Works, and the General Company for Roads and Bridges. 

On February 19, the minister told Al-Watan that the above companies, in cooperation with military-affiliated construction companies, had begun manufacturing 300 one- and two-room prefabricated units. However, in other statements, put that number at 350. He added the units would be ready within a month. The military construction companies affiliated with the Ministry of Defence are the Military Housing Establishment and the Military Construction Establishment. 

Confusion over the number of units emerged in an exceptional session by the Council of Ministers on March 4. The session aimed to discuss “the special procedures for programmes to implement the national action plan and move to the recovery phase for addressing the impacts of the earthquake”. During this session, ministers stressed quick preparation and installation of some 400 “rooms”. The rooms would be fully equipped and distributed to Lattakia and Aleppo governorates as temporary housing for residents impacted by the earthquake. Notably, the ministerial session referred in its discussion to prefabricated “rooms”, rather than to one- or two-room standalone housing units. This could help to explain the increase in the stated number from 300 units to 400 rooms. 

The prefabricated housing units location

The Minister of Public Works and Housing also stated on February 20 that he had been given direct orders to determine sites for constructing buildings in the Aleppo and Lattakia governorates to accommodate 300 apartments in the residential projects implemented by the GHE. Based on the minister’s words, these apartments appear like the prefabricated housing units.

The pro-regime Athr Press news website reported on February 22 that 50 housing units were allocated for Lattakia and would be distributed to three centres: Damserkho and Al-Gharaf in Lattakia city and Al-Naqaa in Jabla. Each centre is between 16 and 20 square metres. 

It is unclear where Aleppo’s share of prefabricated housing units will be located.

The prefabricated housing units cost 

The deputy head of engineering in Aleppo’s Chamber of Industry told the official Al-Baath newspaper on February 23 that Syrian industrialists had submitted tenders for building the prefabricated housing units. Each unit would cost at most SYP 20 million, equivalent to approximately USD 2,700 (1 USD/SYP 7,400 on the black market). 

That same day, Al-Watan quoted an engineering expert who said that relying on local companies is better as it would be easier to transport the finished housing units and install them in their allocated locations. The expert added that there is no major difference in costs between prefabricated and ordinary housing units. For both, the cost per square metre is SYP 700,000-800,000, meaning a 100-square-metre unit would cost about SYP 80 million, or USD 11,000. 

By that logic, a one-room, 25-square-metre prefabricated unit would cost SYP 20 million, in line with the numbers reported by Al-Baath. 

According to the expert quoted in Al-Watan, such units are desirable because they are quick to set up, safe, and designed to resist earthquakes. He also stressed that the government should consider what to do with these housing units in the long-term – including whether they will be converted into permanent housing, which may lead residents to expand them and add certain modifications such as additional storeys. Such modifications could someday lay the foundations for new informal settlements. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-03-07 18:57:352023-03-07 18:59:30Temporary Housing for Syria’s Earthquake-Impacted Residents

Shelter Centres for Earthquake-Impacted Residents in Idlib

07-03-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

Providing shelter for people whose homes were damaged during the February 6 earthquake remains an ongoing challenge for NGOs in Syria. 

The Syrian Salvation Government (SSG), affiliated with the Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham (HTS) group that controls most of the Idlib governorate, has taken on the role of coordinator to direct the response to the dozens of shelter centres that have since appeared, most of them set up in chaos. 

According to a map by the SSG’s General Directorate of Humanitarian Affairs, 52 temporary shelter centres were set up in Idlib and distributed to NGOs responding to the disaster. These centres now house more than 7,500 families or around 37,500 people. Most of these centres were on publicly owned or endowment properties, such as schoolyards, parks, mosques and playgrounds. Others were old, existing encampments already housing people displaced from other parts of Syria. With the owners’ approval, some temporary shelter centres were also set up on privately owned properties. 

According to statistics from the SSG’s Emergency Response Committee, as of March 02, some 10,210 families have been impacted by the earthquake. Not all of them are living in the temporary shelter centres, however. Some stay with relatives, while others erected tents near their destroyed and damaged homes. 

Meanwhile, more than 690 Syrians moved from Turkey to the temporary shelter centres in Idlib as of February 26, according to the General Directorate of Humanitarian Affairs. Ankara had allowed Syrians residing in earthquake-damaged parts of Turkey to return temporarily to Syria in what has come to be known as “earthquake vacation”. According to statistics from the Bab Al-Hawa border crossing, around 15,000 Syrians crossed into Idlib on such trips as of March 01. 

Of the 52 shelter centres, 23 are in Harem and its surrounding countryside, which suffered massive earthquake damage. In that city alone, 35 buildings fully collapsed, and 360 were cracked, killing around 500 people. The surrounding countryside saw the collapse of a newly-built residential project in the town of Basania, killing 200 people. 

Most shelter centres lack essential services such as water, sewage and electricity. Some NGOs have resorted to providing portable bathrooms, installing tanks for drinking and cleaning water, and covering the floors of some centres with gravel. Others set up tents, pour cement floors, and dig waterways to drain sewage water. 

NGOs have also given out tents, mattresses, blankets and meals in coordination with the General Directorate of Humanitarian Affairs to ensure aid reaches all the shelter centres. That said, there is a lack of coordination on the ground, with more than one NGO often distributing aid in one centre. 

Notably, the price of tents has doubled in Idlib due to the huge demand from individuals and NGOs. For example, a medium-quality locally-made tent went from USD 150 to USD 350 after the earthquake. These tents are usually made locally by metalworkers who fashion the iron poles and cut the canvas and plastic insulation. The increased prices have come alongside worsened quality as workers use poorer quality canvas and plastic and employ lower manufacturing standards to keep up with demand. 

The aid response has varied from one area of Idlib governorate to another. Help has still not reached the Al-Maland, Marand, Al-Najia and Badama villages in the countryside west of Jisr Al-Shughour, where residents still urgently need tents. Many of them have been forced to sleep out in the open. 

It is unclear what will happen to the residents of Idlib’s temporary shelter centres in the long term and how long they will reside there. No real steps have been taken to set up new housing for them that is organised and serviced by quality infrastructure. There are also still no plans for restoring damaged homes. Many people now living in these shelters fear they will simply become new camps, added to the dozens of existing camps for forcibly displaced people who came to Idlib from elsewhere in Syria. 

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-03-07 18:48:302023-03-07 18:48:30Shelter Centres for Earthquake-Impacted Residents in Idlib

Armanaz in Idlib after the Earthquake

07-03-2023/in HLP, News /by Rand Shamaa

The local council in the Idlib governorate city of Armanaz has called on residents to submit requests to inspect their homes in earthquake-damaged buildings so that the council could send earthquake damage assessment committees to check on the houses. According to The Syria Report correspondent, 650 such requests were submitted. 

These committees were formed in cooperation with the Engineers’ Syndicate in Idlib, the Directorate of Technical Services and the Ministry of Local Administration, part of the Syrian Salvation Government (SSG) run by the Hay’at Tahrir Al-Sham hardline Islamist group. 

The destruction in Armanaz extended across the newly-built parts of the city and the old city centre, composed of stone houses dating back to various historical periods. The oldest ones contain Byzantine architectural elements. 

According to the damage assessment committees and the Armanaz local council, 11 multi-storey buildings in the city have fully collapsed, containing a total of 135 apartments. Another 36 old homes also fully collapsed. Three multi-storey buildings containing 26 apartments and 60 old houses became at risk of collapse and required demolition. Finally, 26 multi-storey buildings and 60 old houses are cracked, which now require evacuation and restoration work. 

The old city centre: A special case

Destruction from the February 6 quake impacted several neighbourhoods of old Armanaz: Al-Talla, Al-Jabbana, Al-Khodhor, Al-Kharajia, Al-Wadi and Al-Karasi, all of which date back to more than 200 years ago. Three buildings in Al-Jabbana collapsed fully, alongside one home in Al-Kharajia. Meanwhile, Al-Talla, composed of 162 old houses, was the most heavily damaged neighbourhood in the old city, with 35 homes that fully collapsed. Another 45 homes in the area cracked, are now uninhabitable, and cannot be restored. 

The layout of these old houses helped to limit the number of victims, as most of them contained an inner courtyard or garden where residents sought refuge during the earthquake. Al-Talla neighbourhood consists of old Arab-style stone houses with wooden or earthen roofs, though some have concrete roofs. The walls are constructed with what is known as “dak” stone, each about a metre thick and composed of small- and medium-sized stones and earth. 

The alleyways in the old city centre are too narrow for heavy machinery to enter and remove the rubble. The architecture of the old houses there, which consist of arches and vaults, and the construction materials pose challenges to restoring them, some of which are historically valuable. 

Removing collapsed or at-risk houses is also difficult, as many homes are attached and have shared walls. In addition, most residents of these neighbourhoods have limited income and may be unable to afford restoration work or rubble removal. Engineers have warned that leaving these old houses as they are and allowing further exposure to rain and other weather conditions will only exacerbate their disrepair. 

Some engineers have suggested removing several neighbourhoods altogether, which other engineers have rejected. In the meantime, many residents cling to their houses. Local activists say the old neighbourhoods contain important historical sites, including houses, mosques and vaults that date back to various eras and represent the heritage of Armanaz. Some activists have launched a call for relief efforts to help restore the old city centre. 

Some engineers have also suggested implementing the old zoning plans for Armanaz from the 1980s and 1990s, which include constructing wide streets in some old neighbourhoods of the city not classified as historic and compensating residents whose homes would be in the way of those streets. 

Removing the earthquake rubble

Work is ongoing to remove the earthquake rubble in Armanaz. The streets have already been cleared, and debris has been transported to a designated dumping spot. The privately owned Green Energy company, which brings electricity from Turkey and supplies it to Idlib, has repaired electrical lines and replaced broken poles. The local water unit is also restoring the water network and sealing off water flow to demolished buildings to prevent leakage. 

The International Humanitarian Relief Association (IYD), a Turkish NGO, has worked alongside the Syria Civil Defense (known as the White Helmets) to remove rubble from Armanaz and neighbouring Malas and Kafr Takharim and deposit it in designated spots. The IYD also employed around 50 workers to break down the rubble and extract iron and other valuable materials such as aluminium and wood. These were then sold, and the proceeds were given to the owners of those fallen buildings. 

But as for restoring the cracked buildings and homes that can be restored, there still has not been any funding. The SSG-run Ministry of Local Administration issued instructions for repairing such buildings and homes, which must be done under the supervision of the Engineers’ Syndicate. Owners of damaged houses are the ones who must bear the costs of restoration work, while for multi-storey apartment buildings, the residents all share the costs.  

Civil housing initiatives

Armanaz has led the way in social and civil initiatives and has prior experience in such work. In 2017, intense regime airstrikes damaged 127 houses in the city, 70 of which were destroyed, killing 56 people. Syrian expatriates from Armanaz donated to those impacted by the destruction and helped them restore their homes. A similar effort occurred after the February 6 earthquake, with expatriates from the city contributing to residents of damaged homes and victims’ families. 

Armanaz residents, in recent days, also launched the “Seed of Goodness” project to direct aid coming in from donors, especially from expatriates. The project also unifies relief efforts for a permanent housing shelter for earthquake-impacted residents, especially the city’s lowest-income families. In its first stage, the project aims to construct 20 apartments. Volunteers also hope to license a housing association to manage the construction work, which is moving quickly as land for the project has already been purchased, and building and street plans are put in place.

https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Rand Shamaa https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Rand Shamaa2023-03-07 18:41:442023-03-07 18:41:44Armanaz in Idlib after the Earthquake
Page 2 of 3123

Read also

  • A New Classification for Housing Cooperatives: Between Project Completion, Dissolution and Liquidation
  • Decree No. 66 of 2012: Objections and Judicial Proceedings Following the Reparation Package
  • Reconstruction Through Reduced Engineers’ Fees: Engineering Fee Exemptions Fall Short of Enabling Displaced People to Return to Their Areas
  • Rising Rents in Damascus and Its Nearby Suburbs: Demand Pressure and Limited Supply
LinkedIn Logo Twitter Logo
HelpAbout usContact usAdvertise with The Syria ReportTerms & conditions
Copyright © 2026 The Syria Report – all rights reserved. Your use of this website is subject to our legal terms & conditions
Scroll to top

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Ok

Cookie and Privacy Settings



How we use cookies

We may request cookies to be set on your device. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website.

Click on the different category headings to find out more. You can also change some of your preferences. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer.

Essential Website Cookies

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, refuseing them will have impact how our site functions. You always can block or delete cookies by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website. But this will always prompt you to accept/refuse cookies when revisiting our site.

We fully respect if you want to refuse cookies but to avoid asking you again and again kindly allow us to store a cookie for that. You are free to opt out any time or opt in for other cookies to get a better experience. If you refuse cookies we will remove all set cookies in our domain.

We provide you with a list of stored cookies on your computer in our domain so you can check what we stored. Due to security reasons we are not able to show or modify cookies from other domains. You can check these in your browser security settings.

Other external services

We also use different external services like Google Webfonts, Google Maps, and external Video providers. Since these providers may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

Google Webfont Settings:

Google Map Settings:

Google reCaptcha Settings:

Vimeo and Youtube video embeds:

en_USEnglish
en_USEnglish