The Suspended Right of Return for People Displaced from Homs: Destroyed Housing and Repair Costs Turn Return into a Privilege
Since late 2024, some people displaced from Homs’s destroyed neighbourhoods have begun trying to return after years of displacement within Syria or as refugees abroad. They had been forcibly displaced from Jouret Al-Shayyah, Al-Khalidiya, Al-Sabil, Al-Waer and surrounding areas during the sieges and fighting between 2011 and 2017.
Their return quickly revealed a wide gap between the announcement of rubble-removal and service-rehabilitation projects and returnees’ actual ability to recover or repair their homes. Housing has become the decisive condition for return: many homes have been reduced to rubble or left looted, burnt and structurally unsafe, while repair costs and rents exceed the means of most returnees and displaced people.
This gap subjects the right of return to a practical test of the ability of local authorities, organisations and donors to move from rubble removal and partial interventions towards a clear policy for repairing homes, providing reparations, protecting property and clarifying the zoning and legal status of destroyed areas. In the absence of such a framework, return becomes a selective process, available to those with money or a home that can be repaired but effectively closed to those who have lost their homes, documents and safety nets.
Housing as the First Condition for Return
Ahmed, known as “Abu Farhan,” summed up the dilemma of returning to Homs when he told Green Tabu, “There is no house for me to repair.” He was speaking about his home in Jouret Al-Shayyah in central Homs, a predominantly Sunni neighbourhood that was home to relatively affluent middle-class and business communities before the war and later became one of the city’s most severely damaged neighbourhoods.
Ahmed’s home stood on one of the former front lines, which, according to him, resulted in the destruction of his street and reduced it to rubble. He has therefore ruled out repairing the home. “Repairing it is not part of my plans because my home is rubble, a pile of stones on the ground,” he said. He added that rebuilding or repairing structures with damaged foundations would cost several thousand US dollars, an amount he described as “unimaginable” and beyond the means of someone struggling from day to day to provide for his family.
According to Ahmed, housing is the main obstacle to the return to Homs of people displaced within Syria and refugees abroad. Having a habitable home means, as he put it, “solving half the problem because it removes the burden of rent from the returnee.” Losing a home or seeing it reduced to rubble, by contrast, pushes returnees into a high-cost rental market, particularly in neighbourhoods with services inside the city, where some rents exceed USD 500 per month. In the suburbs, Ahmed said, rents for modest homes are no less than between USD 200 and USD 250 per month.
Destruction Beyond the Reach of Repair Grants
Dr Ali Musharraf Jumaa, a family medicine specialist, told Green Tabu of another obstacle to return to Homs. The problem extends beyond the loss of a home or the high cost of repairing it to the nature of the destruction itself: many homes were looted and burnt and had structural elements removed, making them, in some cases, more expensive to repair than a new home would be to build.
Dr Ali moved into his home in 2006, after fitting it out and selecting all its new furniture. The home consisted of two bedrooms, a sitting room and a large kitchen. It held particular family significance for him, as it was where he began his married life, where his 2 children, Razan and Ahmed, were born and raised, and where he began building an independent family and professional life. That life was soon interrupted as violence escalated in Homs. In May 2011, Dr Ali was detained for two months, and in July of the same year his family was forcibly displaced for the 1st time.
The family’s displacement began on Cairo Street in Al-Sabil, adjacent to Al-Khalidiya, Karm Al-Shami and Al-Bayada, where the street formed a dividing line and flashpoint between the neighbourhoods. Dr Ali and his family moved, as he recounted, from one neighbourhood to another within Homs before eventually settling in Al-Waer, which endured a crippling siege between 2013 and 2017. Following the 2017 evacuation agreement for Al-Waer, Dr Ali was forcibly displaced to Idlib Governorate in northern Syria. In late 2024, he returned to Homs, where he and his colleagues formed a voluntary medical committee that provided technical and professional oversight of the city’s hospitals.
When he considered returning to his home, Dr Ali found that repairing it would, by his estimate, cost more than building a new home. The house, he said, had been “completely looted and burnt.” He explained that the first wave of looting targeted its furniture and doors in 2011, which were later sold in markets. A more dangerous phase followed in 2014, when reinforcing steel was stolen from the roofs and columns of buildings in an organised and widespread manner. The damage was therefore no longer confined to furniture or interior finishing but affected the structural safety of the building itself.
Dr Ali tried to find an alternative way to repair his home and registered with several humanitarian organisations and donors working to rehabilitate damaged homes. When he followed up with them, he found that his name had indeed been included on the repair lists for the first year. According to Dr Ali, however, financial support and humanitarian programmes soon declined under the pressure of the large number of returnees needing their homes repaired and the resulting financial burden, which the organisations were unable to bear.
Dr Ali’s experience reveals the limits of partial interventions in a city where some neighbourhoods suffered compound destruction. Returning to a burnt and looted home stripped of reinforcing steel requires more than a door, a window and a few initial repairs; it requires a structural assessment, substantial funding and a clear rehabilitation process. With repair programmes suspended or limited, a returnee is left with a home they legally own but cannot inhabit in practice.
A Tent Amid the Rubble
Retired teacher Mayada Al-Halawani told Green Tabu of another dimension to the obstacles preventing return to Homs, one connected to family life after years of displacement and the direct impact of the absence of housing on women, older people, the ill and children living abroad. Mayada’s return to the city offered no path to stability and instead confronted her again with the most basic problem of shelter, leaving a family that had lost its home, could not repair it and could not afford rent with nowhere to live.
Mayada lived in Al-Khalidiya and worked in education when military operations began in the area at the start of the revolution in Homs. She recounted taking her three children and hurriedly leaving the neighbourhood in search of safety. In 2013, she resigned from education because of the considerable difficulties and risks involved in reaching and working at the school.
After leaving Al-Khalidiya, Mayada and her children spent years moving from place to place within Homs before reaching Al-Waer. There, the family lived under siege for three years amid shortages of food and medicine. In 2017, Mayada and her children were able to move to Hama Governorate and then to Turkey, where they lived for years on income from her work and without a stable support network.
Following the fall of the Assad regime, Mayada decided to return to Homs. She found her home in Al-Khalidiya uninhabitable and was unable to repair it. She currently lives in Hama Governorate with her ill husband, staying temporarily in a relative’s home, while her children remain in Turkey because there is no home in Homs in which the family can be reunited.
Mayada approached Homs Governorate several times seeking a solution for herself and others in similar circumstances, but she said she had received no clear answer as to whether the governorate intended to undertake reconstruction or help affected families recover their homes. She explained that she faced two harsh options: renting a separate flat, which was impossible because of high rents and her lack of financial means, or setting up a shelter tent amid the rubble of her home in Al-Khalidiya and living there with her husband.
Mayada’s situation shows that return is obstructed when both housing and a public policy for shelter, repair and reparation are absent. The family left Al-Khalidiya under pressure from military operations, endured the siege of Al-Waer and was then displaced to Hama and Turkey. Years later, it is left with a property that provides no shelter, a city that offers no alternative and a local administration that gives no clear answer about the future of destroyed areas.
Between the Figures and the Limits of Return
The preceding testimonies place the official figures on housing damage in Homs against conditions on the ground. On 2 May 2026, the Directorate of Planning and Statistics at the Ministry of Local Administration and Environment, in cooperation with the United Nations Human Settlements Programme (UN-Habitat), issued the second package of damage and needs assessment reports for Homs Governorate, based on data from the final quarter of 2025. According to figures announced by the ministry, 5.2 percent of residential units had been completely destroyed, 7 percent had suffered severe damage, 9 percent moderate damage and 10.1 percent minor damage, while 68.8 percent of homes had retained their structural integrity.
These figures present an aggregate picture at the governorate level, but do not in themselves reveal the impact of destruction in neighbourhoods that were centres of sieges and fighting or lay along front lines within Homs, such as Al-Khalidiya, Jouret Al-Shayyah, Al-Sabil, Al-Waer and surrounding areas. In these neighbourhoods, the obstacle to return lies less in the overall damage percentage than in the concentration of destruction in specific streets and buildings and the nature of the damage caused to some homes by shelling, looting, burning and the removal of reinforcing steel. A person may still legally own a home, yet it may remain uninhabitable or so expensive to repair that return becomes impossible in practice.
Alongside the damage assessments, local authorities began presenting rubble-removal and recycling projects as an entry point for urban recovery. On 26 March 2026, a rubble-removal and recycling project was launched in Homs in the presence of Homs Governor Abdul Rahman Al-Aama, Homs City Council President Bashar Al-Sibai and representatives of Etihad Al-Omran, which represents the Turkish company Erkış. Work began in the old bus station area and was to expand gradually into damaged neighbourhoods, with rubble from demolished properties transported to designated centres for processing and recycling into usable construction materials.
Al-Sibai estimated the volume of rubble in Homs at more than 8 million cubic metres. He said the joint work would continue for approximately 3 years and that rubble was being removed from private properties at their owners’ request before work moved on to public properties.
On 23 April 2026, the state-run Syrian Arab News Agency (SANA) reported that Homs City Council, in cooperation with the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), was continuing rubble-removal work in the southern Deir Baalba neighbourhood as part of a plan covering 13 neighbourhoods in the city. According to Samer Al-Mohammad, head of project supervision at the Homs City Council Directorate of Public Works, the project aimed to clear streets closed by accumulated rubble, pave the way for residents to return to and repair their homes, and improve traffic and services.
These projects open roads and remove some immediate physical obstacles, but they alone do not address the central problem raised by returnees: the home itself. Removing rubble from the street or recycling debris does not mean that a family is able to rebuild a burnt, looted, or structurally damaged house. Removing rubble from private property at the owners’ request also assumes that owners are able to initiate and follow up on the process and bear the cost of subsequent stages, while many displaced people are unable to finance repairs or rent alternative accommodation during the waiting period.
Broader humanitarian data supports this contrast between the desire to return and the ability to settle. In February 2025, the Norwegian Refugee Council (NRC) said it had surveyed 4,106 displaced people in northwest Syria between 10 December 2024 and 7 January 2025 to assess their intentions to return following the fall of the former government. Among the 1,600 respondents who had been able to visit their areas of origin, 72 percent said their homes had been completely destroyed or were uninhabitable, while 19 percent said their homes required substantial repairs or reconstruction. These percentages are not specific to Homs, but they provide a general framework for understanding what people displaced from Homs face when inspecting their homes after years of displacement.
FairPlanet, a Berlin-based non-profit media platform focusing on human rights and environmental justice, reported on 12 May 2025, in a report on some Homs residents returning to looted and destroyed homes, that Homs was among the Syrian cities most severely damaged and that the war had left an estimated 5.3 million tonnes of rubble there.
Although this estimate uses a different unit of measurement from that used by Homs City Council, it is consistent with the picture presented by local testimonies: the problem extends beyond the presence of rubble to the scale of destruction that transformed entire neighbourhoods into areas that are difficult to inhabit without extensive structural and financial intervention.
These obstacles intersect with the absence of a clear vision for reconstruction in Homs and Syria more broadly. Weak funding, the absence of a national framework for reconciliation and transitional justice, and uncertainty surrounding the future of zoning plans in destroyed areas all delay the decision to return or make it fraught with risk.
