After Valuation Tables Are Cancelled in Hama: Judicial Appraisals Raise Rents for Shops Under the Furoogh System
On 11 March 2026, the council of the Hama branch of the Engineers’ Syndicate adopted tables of prevailing market values for commercial and residential properties and agricultural land in Hama city and its surrounding area, to serve as an indicative reference for experts conducting judicial appraisals. The value of a commercial property subject to compulsory lease extension directly affects its rent: Rental Law No. 20 of 2015 sets the annual rent at 7 percent of the value of the leased premises on the date the lawsuit is filed. The high values listed in the tables therefore prompted protests by holders of furoogh rights, some of whom closed their shops in several of the city’s markets on 26 April 2026.
On 7 May 2026, representatives of furoogh rights holders met with officials in Hama and subsequently announced that the general tables had been cancelled, while individual rent revaluation lawsuits remained in place. The law allows both lessors and lessees to request that the rent be reassessed if either alleges unfairness in the amount, provided that no such claim has been filed within the previous 3 years.
From Preparing the Tables to Announcing Their Cancellation
The process of preparing the tables began on 31 December 2025, when the head of the Hama branch of the Engineers’ Syndicate issued Decision No. 199/1. The decision established a committee of 7 engineers to prepare estimated values for commercial, residential and agricultural properties in Hama governorate and set the principles for preparing expert reports. The committee was chaired by Osama Baghdadi and included Raad Atallah, Sobhi Al-Sheikh Sobh, Gandhi Abu Ali, Abdul Razzaq Halqawi, Abdul Rahim Haddad and Ahmad Al-Razouq. Among the grounds cited in the decision was a letter that the “Hama Furoogh Rights Holders Committee” had sent to the Syndicate branch on 24 December 2025.
The tables were particularly significant for tenants of older commercial shops subject to compulsory lease extension, under which a lease continues automatically after its term expires regardless of the lessor’s wishes. These include permanent commercial leases known as furoogh contracts. Under this older system, the tenant pays the landlord a lump sum at the outset of the tenancy, in addition to periodic rent that is often nominal. The tenant may transfer the right to occupy the shop to another tenant in return for a new furoogh payment, while ownership of the property remains with the original landlord.
The engineers’ committee said it had prepared the tables after conducting field surveys, studying planning, urban and commercial conditions, and analysing the factors affecting property values. The study covered streets in Hama city, communities in its northern countryside and the town of Kafr Buhum, and classified values for commercial premises, residential properties and land. On 11 March 2026, the council of the Hama branch of the Engineers’ Syndicate approved the committee’s minutes and deemed the tables “advisory and indicative” for engineers accredited as experts by the Ministry of Justice. The Syndicate branch referred the tables to the Attorney General in Hama under Letter No. 1183 on 15 March 2026. The number 1183 therefore refers to the letter by which the tables were transmitted, rather than to the decision establishing the committee or approving the tables.
Holders of furoogh rights argued that experts’ use of these tables as a reference in rent revaluation lawsuits would raise the assessed values of leased premises and, consequently, their annual rents. Faced with a shared concern, furoogh rights holders in Hama gradually developed a representative framework. Their public mobilisation began under the name “Hama Traders’ Group” during a protest on 9 November 2025. The name “Hama Furoogh Rights Holders Committee” then appeared in correspondence with the Engineers’ Syndicate branch in December 2025. From April 2026, the name “Committee for the Protection of Furoogh Rights Holders” was used for the body that submitted the rights holders’ objections, communicated with judicial authorities, the Engineers’ Syndicate and the Chamber of Commerce, and organised protests and strikes.
A member of the “Committee for the Protection of Furoogh Rights Holders” told Green Tabu that the values in the tables treated as equivalent shops located on streets that differed in location and level of commercial activity. He added: “The central issue in Hama is arbitrary valuation,” arguing that the engineers’ committee had failed to account for differences between main and secondary streets or between shop locations on the same street.
According to figures that representatives of the “Committee for the Protection of Furoogh Rights Holders” provided to Green Tabu, the annual rent for some small shops rose under the valuation tables from SYP 250,000 to SYP 40 million, an increase of more than 15,000 percent. The new annual rent reached SYP 28 million for a warehouse, SYP 95 million for a vegetable shop and SYP 450 million for Al-Sharq Cinema.
These values prompted the “Committee for the Protection of Furoogh Rights Holders” to call for a strike on 26 April 2026. Traders closed their shops on Al-Dabbagha Street, Ibn Rushd Street and in Al-Tawil Market, and held a protest outside Al-Sultan Mosque. They demanded that use of the tables be halted and that the engineers’ committee disclose the criteria it had applied.
On 7 May 2026, representatives of furoogh rights holders met with the Attorney General in Hama, Mohammad Ahmad Al-Naasan; the head of the Engineers’ Syndicate branch; and representatives of the Hama Chamber of Commerce. The rights holders’ representatives said the meeting ended with a promise to stop using the tables and to establish an arbitration committee under the Chamber of Commerce’s auspices. With the agreement of both parties to the lease, this committee would consider either ending the rental relationship or setting a new rent. Following the meeting, the representatives announced that the general tables had been cancelled, although no official decision to that effect had been issued. Individual judicial rent revaluation lawsuits remained active, with an appraisal by a 3-member panel available when the initial appraisal was challenged. The continuation of individual cases shifted the dispute towards expert reports issued separately in each lawsuit.
Rent Revaluation Lawsuits and the Rights of Both Parties to the Lease
Rental Law No. 20 of 2015 regulates the reassessment of rents for older properties subject to compulsory lease extension. Both lessors and lessees may file a lawsuit before the Magistrates’ Court if either alleges unfairness in the rent, meaning an unjust disparity between the amount paid and the amount determined under the law. The annual rent for property used for commercial, industrial or artisanal purposes is calculated at 7 percent of the value of the leased premises on the date the lawsuit is filed. The lessee continues to pay the previous rent until a final ruling is issued, after which the new rent applies from the date the claim was filed.
A new lawsuit to determine the rent may be filed only once every 3 years, calculated from the date of the contract, a written agreement to amend the rent or the previous claim. This mechanism helps explain why owners of long-leased commercial properties under the furoogh system have resorted to the courts after inflation eroded the real value of rents. It also allows tenants to seek a reduction if they believe the rent exceeds the amount legally due for the leased premises.
The law allows the Magistrates’ Court to appoint either 1 expert or 3 experts to estimate the property’s value. The parties may agree on their selection. If they cannot agree, each party nominates an expert from the roster issued by decision of the Minister of Justice, and the court selects the third. The panel submits its report after inspecting the leased premises and examining its characteristics, location, area, use and the factors affecting its value. Depending on the course of the case, the court may adopt the report, request that it be supplemented or order a new appraisal.
The effect of this mechanism can be seen in a lawsuit involving a commercial shop rented under the furoogh system in Hama’s Al-Tawil Market, where Obada Abideen inherited the right to occupy the premises from his grandfather. The shop’s bare owners filed the lawsuit on 28 August 2024, seeking a reassessment of the rent. On 25 May 2026, the court ordered an appraisal by a 3-member panel of experts. The experts inspected the shop on 12 July 2026 and submitted their report on 19 July 2026.
The expert panel valued the shop at approximately SYP 1.9 billion and set its annual rent at SYP 133 million, equivalent to 7 percent of the estimated value. The panel appraisal followed Abideen’s objection to an earlier valuation that, he said, had set the annual rent at SYP 58 million. Rather than lowering the rent, the new appraisal raised it by more than 129 percent compared with the previous valuation.
The expert report took into account the shop’s location, area, structural characteristics and commercial use, and referred to the equipment and improvements within it. These details matter in shops held under furoogh leases because the tenant may have paid a substantial sum at the beginning of the rental relationship and acquired a financial interest in the shop, then paid to fit it out and improve it, while the landlord retains bare ownership. Appraising the leased premises on the basis of the property’s current real estate value raises the annual rent without, by itself, resolving how the furoogh right or the value of tenant-financed improvements should be calculated.
This dispute coincides with campaigns led by some bare owners of commercial shops demanding the return of their properties. Some participants in these campaigns describe occupants holding furoogh rights as “usurpers of their shops.” Fadi Jammad, a lawyer specialising in real estate disputes and property rights, told Green Tabu that this description lacks a legal basis because a holder of furoogh rights occupies the property under a contract and on legal grounds. Jammad said that property extortion, by contrast, entails taking possession of a property by force and without legal basis.
Jammad added that the heirs of a bare owner succeed the deceased in both rights and obligations. Ownership of the property therefore passes to them, as do the obligations arising from the lease contract if the deceased had received the furoogh payment. He said Law No. 20 of 2015 had established rules governing the relationship between the parties, while economic changes and the erosion of the real value of rents require the law to be updated through provisions that protect both bare owners and holders of furoogh rights. Abideen’s case shows that retaining individual valuation lawsuits shifted the dispute from the general tables to the method used to value each leased property, raising questions about appraisal criteria and the transparency of expert selection.
No Published Criteria and Suspected Conflicts of Interest
The shift from general valuation tables to individual expert reports left the fundamental problem unresolved: the basis on which experts estimate the value of each leased property. A member of the “Committee for the Protection of Furoogh Rights Holders” told Green Tabu that the committee’s representatives asked the head of the Engineers’ Syndicate branch during the meeting on 7 May 2026 about the methodology used to determine the elements of a valuation and the weight assigned to each. They received no clear answer. The member added that the discussion ended with a statement that the tables and the files on which the experts had relied had been lost, with no explanation of which body was responsible for preserving them or how they could be consulted when an appraisal was challenged.
The absence of published criteria prevents interested parties from determining the effect of each factor on the final value, including a shop’s position on a street, the level of commercial activity, its area, structural condition, the nature of the business operating there, the furoogh right and tenant-financed improvements. It also complicates comparisons between valuations issued in similar lawsuits and makes a challenge dependent on a new appraisal that may produce an even higher figure, as occurred in Obada Abideen’s case.
The “Committee for the Protection of Furoogh Rights Holders” raised suspicions of conflicts of interest involving some experts, on the grounds that they hold bare ownership rights in commercial properties and could benefit from higher values being adopted across the market. Green Tabu compared the names of several engineers appearing in expert-panel documents with official land records and found commercial properties registered in the names of some of them. This shows that some individuals were both experts and property owners. Proving a conflict of interest in a specific case, however, would require establishing that an expert had a direct personal interest in the outcome or a connection to one of the parties.
The “Committee for the Protection of Furoogh Rights Holders” submitted a complaint naming engineers whom it accused of conflicts of interest, but the Hama Chamber of Commerce declined to sign it. The reasons for the Chamber’s refusal, the outcome of the complaint and the identity of the authority that received it remain unclear. Current procedures also lack a published rule requiring experts to disclose property holdings or interests connected to the market in which they appraise properties, or specifying the circumstances in which they must recuse themselves.
In contrast to the high valuations in Hama, traders in Damascus and Aleppo told Green Tabu that rent revaluation lawsuits in their markets had produced figures they considered closer to actual market conditions. This suggests that Hama’s crisis has a local dimension connected to the way appraisals are conducted there, although the comparison remains limited by the absence of published data on the number of cases and average assessed rents in the 3 governorates.
Fears that the crisis could spread to other markets prompted representatives of furoogh rights holders and bare owners in Damascus to work on establishing committees within chambers of commerce and industry. Similar initiatives emerged in some professional syndicates and artisans’ unions. This organisation aims to provide representation for both parties in discussions over amendments to the Rental Law and the management of disputes arising from old contracts.
The effects of the appraisals extend to commerce more broadly and to consumer prices. A member of the “Committee for the Protection of Furoogh Rights Holders” said that raising a shop’s annual rent from around SYP 2 million to SYP 30 million or SYP 40 million would force traders to pass the increase on through the prices of goods, particularly in a city that relies on Damascus and Aleppo for a significant share of its supplies. He added that traders would be caught between the new rental costs and the profit margins allowed by price-control authorities, estimating that some increases could push the prices of goods to between 5 and 10 times their previous levels. This figure remains an estimate by the committee, unsupported by accounting data that would allow it to be generalised.
The Hama crisis highlights the need for rent revaluation lawsuits to be governed by written, published criteria; reports that explain how values are calculated; a mechanism requiring experts to disclose their interests and recuse themselves in cases of conflict; and data allowing judgements and expert appraisals to be compared across markets. Amendments to the Rental Law must also address the erosion of the real value of rents while protecting the financial value acquired by holders of furoogh rights, rather than leaving the rebalancing of the relationship to inconsistent individual appraisals that may pass the cost of the dispute on to traders and consumers.
Restoring Balance Through the Law
The furoogh crisis in Hama shows that efforts to correct the imbalance in rental relationships have moved away from a single statutory framework and towards a series of inconsistent appraisals whose underlying principles are difficult for the parties to identify and whose outcomes are difficult to predict. This process gives engineering appraisals a role that extends beyond estimating property values to redistributing the burden created by inflation between the bare owner and the holder of furoogh rights, although both rely on existing legal rights.
Restoring balance requires amendments to the Rental Law that establish a clear, periodic mechanism for adjusting rents and distinguish among the property’s value, the furoogh right and improvements financed by the tenant. It also requires standardised, published valuation criteria, an obligation for experts to disclose their interests, and reasoned reports that can be challenged and compared. Such safeguards would move the dispute away from fluctuating individual estimates and towards rules that can be scrutinised, and would prevent the erosion of owners’ rights from being addressed by weakening the financial right acquired by the tenant.
