Visit The Syria Report Subscribe to our mailing list
EN ع
  • Twitter
Syria Report
  • Green Tabu
    • Issues
    • Updates
    • Analysis
    • Policy Briefs
    • Interviews
  • Archive
    • All articles
    • News
    • Analysis & Features
    • Reports & Papers
    • Regulations
    • Directory
  • Search
  • Menu Menu
Home1 / HLP2 / Green Tabu3 / Rubble Removal in Rural Damascus: From Transportation Costs to Proving Rights4
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Rubble Removal in Rural Damascus: From Transportation Costs to Proving Rights

19-10-2026/in Green Tabu, Updates /by Mazen Ezzi

Rural Damascus Governorate recently reactivated Law No. 3 of 2018 on the removal of rubble from damaged buildings through a series of decisions bringing Darayya, Sayyida Zainab, Al-Husseiniya, and Zabadani under its provisions. These decisions give local administrative units a direct role in assessing the scale of the damage, the cost of removal, and the equipment required, in preparation for dealing with large quantities of rubble that continue to obstruct partial returns, the repair of homes, and the restoration of services in areas that suffered varying degrees of wartime destruction.

Local councils present this process as a means of reducing the direct burden on owners of damaged properties, after rubble removal became a cost that many residents could not bear alone. This gives the inclusion decisions a clear service-related and social dimension, as they move the rubble issue from scattered individual initiatives into an administrative process managed by the governorate and local authorities.

The application of Law No. 3 in Rural Damascus, however, reveals tension between the declared administrative promise and the law’s actual mechanism. The law regulates the removal and sale of rubble by public auction and the deposit of the proceeds into a special account for those entitled to them, after deducting removal and transportation costs. It also allows for the formation of a Building Description and Ownership Verification Committee, chaired by a cadastral judge and including administrative, technical and community representatives. The committee is responsible for describing damaged buildings and preliminarily verifying those entitled to the rubble and private possessions. Its tables do not, however, replace the Land Registry or constitute a process for restoring damaged real estate documents. 

The inclusion decisions assign the rubble removal law a broader function than its actual scope. They may move the rubble issue forward, reduce the direct cost to residents, and create an opportunity to collect documents and evidence that help organise rights holders’ files. They nevertheless remain governed by limited safeguards, particularly concerning the right to object to the classification of a building’s condition or to its demolition, the rights of absent and displaced owners, the fate of the land after the rubble is removed, and disputes that extend beyond ownership of the rubble and private possessions to the underlying ownership of the property itself. 

Inclusion decisions and the scale of the rubble

The Rural Damascus Governorate issued decisions including Darayya, Sayyida Zainab, Al-Husseiniya, and Zabadani under Law No. 3 of 2018 on the removal of rubble from damaged buildings. The decisions come at a time when rubble remains one of the main obstacles to partial returns of displaced residents, home repairs, and the restoration of services across large areas of Rural Damascus. The cost of removal exceeds the means of many owners of damaged properties, particularly those whose buildings have been completely or almost completely destroyed.

The 4 inclusion decisions, issued on September 5 under Nos. 3261–3264, have administrative significance beyond the 4 towns they cover. They establish a process that could be extended to other towns and cities in Rural Damascus and possibly to other governorates containing large quantities of rubble. At its current stage, however, the process remains limited to removing rubble and describing damaged buildings. It is not sufficient on its own to address lost or undocumented property rights. 

Law No. 3 authorises the governor to identify the cadastral area and damaged buildings to which its provisions will apply, based on a proposal from the relevant administrative unit. Once the inclusion decision has been issued, the administrative unit must prepare a detailed report within 120 days. The report must set out the scale and percentage of damage, the expected costs, and the equipment needed to remove rubble from public and private property. It must also estimate the value expected to be recovered from the rubble and include a plan showing images of the damaged buildings, the names of the cadastral areas, the names of the building owners, and details of private possessions. 

In Darayya, the scale of the rubble problem appears to be one of the reasons for resorting to this process. Raed Obeid, head of Darayya City Council, told Green Tabu that there were an estimated 1.3 million cubic metres of rubble in the city—earlier estimates had only been around 500,000 cubic metres. The difference between the two estimates shows that the volume of rubble exceeds initial calculations and that dealing with it requires organised intervention by the governorate and the administrative unit, rather than individual initiatives by owners of damaged properties.

According to Obeid, the governorate will pay for rubble removal in Darayya through contracts with public or private bodies to carry out the work. This would reduce the direct burden on residents, who have struggled with rubble-removal costs, particularly owners of partially destroyed properties. His statement reflects the service-related and social dimension of the inclusion decisions, because removing rubble is no longer linked to each owner’s ability to pay but has become part of a general administrative process led by the governorate and local authorities.

The wording of the law nevertheless requires a more precise reading of the question of cost. The law provides for rubble removed and transported by the administrative unit to be sold at public auctions. The value of the final auction award is then deposited in a special account in the name of the administrative unit for the benefit of those entitled to it, after the costs of removing and transporting the rubble have been deducted. In recent statements by local officials, removal is therefore presented as a public service that reduces the immediate burden on property owners, while under the law, it is also linked to the value of the rubble and a subsequent mechanism for covering removal and transportation costs.

This creates a distinction between officials’ promises and the law’s actual mechanism. The governorate and local councils present the inclusion decisions as a way of easing the burden on residents and removing a physical obstacle to repairs and return. The law, however, links the process to assessing damage, determining the value of the rubble, selling it, and deducting removal costs from the resulting proceeds. In other words, the cost does not disappear entirely. Instead, it shifts from a direct advance payment by owners to a subsequent legal mechanism connected to the value of the rubble and the rights of its owners.

Obeid said the effect of rubble removal would be limited to helping residents dispose of the debris, without connecting the process to updates to zoning plans or to any reconstruction project. He also explained that rehabilitating homes remains the responsibility of their owners and may later take place through agreements between them and real estate development companies. This distinction is essential: removing rubble is not the same as reconstruction, nor does it automatically give owners of damaged properties the financial or legal capacity to repair their homes or construct new buildings in place of those destroyed by the war. 

In Al-Husseiniya, the implementation process appears from another perspective. Youssef Yaqoub, head of the city council, told Green Tabu that a committee of engineers would inspect damaged homes, assess each one and then prioritise rubble removal according to the scale of destruction and after obtaining the property owner’s approval. He also said that there was not yet a clear and accurate estimate of the quantity of rubble in the city, and that the estimated level of destruction was approximately 20 percent. The local council had begun compiling statistics on the number of damaged homes in preparation for submitting a detailed report to the governorate. 

The accounts from Darayya and Al-Husseiniya show that the inclusion decisions are still at the stage of moving from legal text to local implementation. In Darayya, the large volume of rubble makes removal an immediate priority, while in Al-Husseiniya the urgent need is for engineering inspection and the setting of priorities before work begins. In both cases, the implementation of Law No. 3 remains dependent on the ability of administrative units to prepare accurate reports, secure implementing bodies, estimate costs, and deal with rubble as property belonging to rights holders rather than simply as construction waste that can be removed by administrative decision.

From Establishing Ownership to Preliminary Verification of Ownership 

Darayya provides the clearest example of the overlap between rubble removal and the property documentation crisis. The scale of the rubble in the city raises not only questions about cost and transportation mechanisms, but also a more complicated issue involving the proof of rights over properties whose buildings were damaged or completely destroyed, whose owners’ documents were damaged or lost, and whose records serving as reference points in property disputes were themselves affected.

According to Obeid, the most important aspect of the inclusion decisions is the regularisation of property ownership. He explained that the 2012 destruction of the Darayya Palace of Justice, which housed the Land Registry office, damaged the principal register of property ownership. This left the city facing a serious documentation problem, particularly in relation to agricultural properties and informal settlements. Obeid said the committee to be formed under Law No. 3 would rely on documents held by property owners rather than referring every case directly to the courts, since judicial proceedings could take a long time. 

Describing this process as the regularisation of property ownership, however, requires legal scrutiny. Law No. 3 does not give the Building Description and Ownership Verification Committee the authority to restore damaged real estate documents, nor does it make the committee’s tables a substitute for the Land Registry or equivalent records of property ownership. The committee’s role is to inventory, record and describe damaged buildings, conduct a preliminary verification of ownership, and then prepare a table containing the owners’ names, their shares, and the necessary information relating to private possessions, rubble and buildings included in the removal process. Preliminary verification does not provide the rights holder with a new title deed or amend the Land Registry records. It merely organises a table of rights holders for the purposes of removing the rubble, dealing with private possessions and distributing the resulting proceeds. 

In this sense, the inclusion decisions in Rural Damascus create a practical process for rights holders who possess ownership documents of varying legal value, but they do not, on their own, resolve the issue of property ownership in a final sense. The committee may rely on subdivision plans, lists of owners, official documents and papers, proof of payment of electricity and water bills, records from financial departments, testimony from neighbours concerning ownership of the property, and physical inspection, meaning an on-site examination of the property or its location. These tools may help to build a preliminary evidentiary file, but they remain connected to rubble-removal procedures and the organisation of the owners’ rights in the rubble. They do not constitute the issuance of new title deeds or the reconstruction of a damaged Land Registry.

The procedures required of residents are consistent with this preliminary form of verification. The inclusion decisions require owners of properties, private possessions and rubble, or their legal representatives or relatives up to the fourth degree, to submit an application to the city council within 30 days of the announcement. The application must state their place of residence and be accompanied by documents supporting their rights, or copies where the originals are unavailable. For clarity, rubble means the remains of a collapsed building, while private possessions refer to items inside the property, such as furniture, tools or other recoverable objects. The application must also state the property’s location and boundaries, the relevant shares, its legal nature and legal classification, and details of the private possessions or claimed rights. 

Obeid explained that a property owner in Darayya may submit any available document, such as a water or electricity bill, together with testimony from neighbours confirming that the property belongs to them, where the owner does not possess a formal contract, court judgment or judicial power of attorney. This mechanism reflects a local attempt to adapt the law to the destruction of documents and records. It nevertheless gives the committee broad discretion in assessing evidence, particularly where ownership is based on undocumented transactions, informal contracts or community testimony that may be difficult to verify independently of potential disputes. 

The process becomes more sensitive where there is a conflict between two parties. According to Obeid, the matter is referred to the courts where one party claims to have bought the property from another, while the second party denies the sale and there is no document or contract proving the claim. Such cases fall outside the committee’s preliminary administrative and legal function and return the matter to the judiciary, because the committee cannot resolve a serious dispute over the underlying right where claims conflict and decisive documents are absent.

The forms distributed by Darayya City Council to applicants beginning on June 10 therefore appear to be part of an organisational attempt to collect preliminary information rather than an alternative to complete real estate documentation. The forms include a description of the property, its location, the extent of the damage and the documents submitted by the owner to prove their right. This information helps organise inspections and removal and identify the parties concerned, but it is not sufficient on its own to resolve property disputes dating from before the destruction or arising from transactions conducted during forced displacement, internal displacement or the absence of rights holders. 

This demonstrates the limits of relying on Law No. 3 to address property ownership. Local decisions may use it to collect residents’ documents, organise preliminary tables and identify those entitled to rubble and private possessions. They go beyond the wording of the law, however, when they present it as a framework for establishing lost property rights or restoring their documentation. The difference between establishing ownership and carrying out preliminary verification is not merely linguistic but concerns the legal effect of the procedure on rights. Establishing ownership produces a stable legal effect, whereas preliminary verification involves collecting evidence sufficient to administer rubble removal and the associated proceeds and private possessions. 

Darayya represents a genuine test of the ability of the inclusion decisions to protect rights holders without assigning Law No. 3 a function it does not provide for. In a city where both buildings and records were damaged, the rubble-removal process may offer an opportunity to collect documents at risk of being lost and create an initial local archive concerning damaged properties. It will remain incomplete, however, unless accompanied by another legal framework addressing the restoration of damaged real estate documents, the protection of absent owners and the resolution of disputes extending beyond ownership of rubble and private possessions to the underlying ownership of the property itself. 

Limited safeguards under Law No. 3

The inclusion decisions move from the stage of administrative announcement to implementation through a series of technical and legal procedures. These begin with the inspection of damaged buildings, the assessment of the scale of damage, the setting of priorities and the preparation of tables of rights holders, followed by the removal of rubble or its sale at public auction. At this stage, the limits of Law No. 3 become more apparent. It gives administrative units and specialised committees broad tools for managing the rubble issue but provides owners and rights holders with only limited safeguards, particularly concerning the classification of a building’s condition, objections to demolition and the fate of the land after the rubble has been removed. 

The first limitation becomes apparent when local statements about implementing the inclusion decisions are compared with the text of the law itself. Some local councils present rubble removal as a consensual process involving property owners and based on technical inspection, the setting of priorities and the owner’s approval. Law No. 3, however, does not make the owner’s approval a general and prior condition for every removal operation. Instead, it regulates the deadlines for submitting applications, recovering private possessions or rubble, and objecting to the table of rights holders before the Civil Court of Appeal. Approval, where mentioned in local statements, therefore amounts more to an implementing commitment or declared practice than to a legal safeguard sufficient in itself to protect all owners in the areas concerned. 

This distinction is particularly important because the law gives the Building Description and Ownership Verification Committee a central role in describing damaged buildings, determining the amount and percentage of damage, assessing whether a building is structurally sound, and recommending whether it should be demolished fully or partially, or left standing. This authority also affects buildings that remain standing but are at risk of collapse or capable of repair, making the technical description itself a matter with significant consequences for owners’ rights. 

One of the law’s principal weaknesses lies in the narrow scope of objections. The right to appeal before the Civil Court of Appeal relates to the information contained in the table of rights holders and does not provide a clear procedure for objecting to the classification of a building’s condition or to a recommendation that it be demolished. An objection concerning ownership also does not suspend the public-auction proceedings conducted by the administrative unit. A rights holder may challenge the committee’s table while procedures for dealing with or selling the rubble continue, limiting the practical effect of judicial protection. 

Another problem concerns the fate of the land after rubble is removed or a building at risk of collapse is demolished. The law regulates ownership of the rubble and private possessions, the method for selling them, and the preservation of the resulting proceeds, but it does not clearly state what happens to the land once removal is complete. It does not specify whether the owner may immediately construct a new building on the land or whether this will later be subject to zoning conditions, permits or new zoning plans. Nor does it connect removal to compensation for the land, alternative housing or an expropriation process. This gap is particularly important in destroyed areas such as Darayya, where Obeid has stated that rubble removal is not connected to updates to zoning plans and that the rehabilitation of homes remains the responsibility of residents. 

Removing rubble is, therefore, not sufficient to restore the right to housing or enable an effective return. The administrative unit may remove debris from private property and prepare a table of those entitled to the rubble and private possessions, but the property owner will still require the financial means to repair or rebuild, administrative permits, clarity concerning the zoning status of the land, and a resolution of any dispute over the underlying ownership. This makes Law No. 3 a tool for managing rubble rather than a framework for reconstruction or reparation for property-related harm. 

The law allows rubble and similar materials to be sold at public auction, after which the value of the successful bid is deposited in a special account for those entitled to it, following the deduction of removal and transportation costs. This process may preserve a financial entitlement for anyone who later proves their claim, but it does not necessarily compensate for the loss of actual control over the rubble or private possessions, or for the limited ability to object within the specified deadlines. Converting rights into a cash payment may also fail to address the owner’s actual loss where the rubble is connected to the property’s location, the possibility of repairing it, or personal memories and belongings. 

The inclusion decisions in Rural Damascus reveal a legal and administrative paradox. They are based on a law that gives local authorities practical tools for removing rubble and preparing preliminary tables of rights holders, yet these tools are being applied to problems that extend beyond the law’s scope: damaged real estate documents, missing documents, absent owners, reconstruction costs, and the fate of the land after the debris is removed. Without a complementary legal framework that addresses the restoration of damaged real estate documents, guarantees the rights of absent owners, and expands the ability to object to building classifications and demolition, the inclusion decisions may move the rubble issue forward but cannot, on their own, protect damaged property rights or establish a safe process for return and repair. 

The limits of the law and the need for amendment

A serious response must begin with amending Law No. 3 of 2018, rather than expanding the inclusion decisions or leaving implementation dependent on promises made by local officials. The law needs to draw a clear distinction between rubble removal, the preliminary verification of rights holders and the restoration of damaged real estate documents. It also needs a more precise definition of the legal effect of the tables prepared by the committees, so that they are not used as an undeclared substitute for the Land Registry or as a means of confirming or denying rights that extend beyond ownership of rubble and private possessions. 

Any amendment should expand the right of objection so that it is not limited to the list of rights holders but also applies to the classification of a building’s condition and recommendations for its demolition or removal. An objection should also suspend procedures capable of causing irreparable harm. The deadlines granted to absent and displaced people should be extended, and a special mechanism should be established to protect those who have lost their documents or are unable to reach their areas or obtain legal representation.

The law also requires a clear provision concerning the fate of the land after rubble removal and the relationship between removal, repair, reconstruction, and compensation. It must explain how removal and transportation costs are calculated, when they are to be borne by the administrative unit, and when they are to be deducted from the value of the rubble, so that reducing the burden on residents does not remain merely an administrative promise. Only then can the rubble issue develop from a limited public-service measure into an organised legal process for protecting housing, land, and property rights in affected areas.

Views: 26
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail
https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png 0 0 Mazen Ezzi https://hlp.syria-report.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Logo-300x81.png Mazen Ezzi2026-10-19 10:42:372026-10-19 10:42:37Rubble Removal in Rural Damascus: From Transportation Costs to Proving Rights

Read also

  • A New Classification for Housing Cooperatives: Between Project Completion, Dissolution and Liquidation
  • Decree No. 66 of 2012: Objections and Judicial Proceedings Following the Reparation Package
  • Reconstruction Through Reduced Engineers’ Fees: Engineering Fee Exemptions Fall Short of Enabling Displaced People to Return to Their Areas
  • Rising Rents in Damascus and Its Nearby Suburbs: Demand Pressure and Limited Supply
LinkedIn Logo Twitter Logo
HelpAbout usContact usAdvertise with The Syria ReportTerms & conditions
Copyright © 2026 The Syria Report – all rights reserved. Your use of this website is subject to our legal terms & conditions
إعادة الإعمار عبر تخفيض أتعاب المهندسين: إعفاءات... Rising Rents in Damascus and Its Nearby Suburbs: Demand Pressure and Limited...
Scroll to top

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Ok

Cookie and Privacy Settings



How we use cookies

We may request cookies to be set on your device. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website.

Click on the different category headings to find out more. You can also change some of your preferences. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer.

Essential Website Cookies

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, refuseing them will have impact how our site functions. You always can block or delete cookies by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website. But this will always prompt you to accept/refuse cookies when revisiting our site.

We fully respect if you want to refuse cookies but to avoid asking you again and again kindly allow us to store a cookie for that. You are free to opt out any time or opt in for other cookies to get a better experience. If you refuse cookies we will remove all set cookies in our domain.

We provide you with a list of stored cookies on your computer in our domain so you can check what we stored. Due to security reasons we are not able to show or modify cookies from other domains. You can check these in your browser security settings.

Other external services

We also use different external services like Google Webfonts, Google Maps, and external Video providers. Since these providers may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

Google Webfont Settings:

Google Map Settings:

Google reCaptcha Settings:

Vimeo and Youtube video embeds:

en_USEnglish
en_USEnglish