Duplicity in Real Estate Ownership Documentation in Raqqa City
Since the city of Raqqa fell out of the control of the Assad regime in 2013, real estate documentation has proceeded along two parallel tracks. The first track was linked to the succession of multiple de facto authorities over the Directorate of Land Registry, and the accompanying suspension of its work, transfer of its documents, and the creation of alternative registers. The second track was represented by the practices adopted by rights holders themselves to preserve their property rights, in the absence of a stable and recognised registration authority.
Raqqa was the first provincial capital to fall completely outside the control of the Assad regime in 2013, coming under the control of armed opposition factions, before being taken over a few months later by the Ahrar Al-Sham Islamist movement. At the end of 2014, the Islamic State (ISIS) seized control of the city, making it the capital of what it called the “Caliphate.” At the end of 2017, the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) fought a fierce battle to expel the group from the city, with support from the U.S.-led International Coalition. Since then, Raqqa has remained under the control of the SDF, along with the Hassakeh Governorate, parts of Deir-ez-Zor Governorate, and areas in the eastern and northeastern countryside of Aleppo. The city of Raqqa is administered by the Raqqa Civil Council, appointed by the Autonomous Administration in North and East Syria (AANES).
The process of preserving real estate ownership in Raqqa went through multiple stages, directly linked to the succession of authorities and the bombardment suffered by the city’s institutions. Former Cadastral Affairs employees told The Syria Report that after armed opposition factions took control of the city in 2013, employees, activists, and members of the armed opposition transferred the real estate documents from the government complex to the old municipal building, following the regime forces’ shelling of the complex.
During its control of the city, the Islamic State created real estate registers derived from the old cadastral records, but bearing its own stamps. The old municipal building itself was soon bombed by the International Coalition during the period of the group’s control, necessitating the transfer of the real estate records, including those created by the group, to the basements of Ibn Khaldoun School. The main and temporary registers, along with contracts and the records of housing associations, youth housing, and savings schemes, were preserved, each in separate rooms.
During the Islamic State’s control of the city, residents were hesitant over documents created by the group, for fear of their lack of legitimacy and the potential consequences of bearing Islamic State stamps. Accordingly, during that period, residents resorted to documenting their sales through customary contracts at some real estate offices. These contracts detailed the chain of ownership ending with the most recent owner of the property.
After the group was expelled from the city, the AANES established a provisional land register attached to the municipality to record sales and property transactions, based on the old official real estate records preserved in the basements of Ibn Khaldoun School. This new register came to be used in practice to safeguard rights, despite the limited legal force it holds outside the courts of the Autonomous Administration.
In April 2023, the Raqqa Civil Council, affiliated with the AANES, prepared a building near the Maternity and Gynaecology Hospital to serve as the headquarters of the Land Registry Office. In June of the same year, all real estate records were transferred from the basements of Ibn Khaldoun School to the new building, which was officially inaugurated on August 12, 2023, affiliated with the Justice Authority of the AANES, which is equivalent to the ministry of justice.
At the same time, the AANES relies on other administrative institutions, including the “Property Documentation Office” in Raqqa Canton, which includes two departments: the first supervises the work of the Land Registry, while the second regulates the financial matters related to the collection of fees for real estate record statements and cadastral statements. Attached to the office is a surveying department responsible for registering and fixing maps of real estate ownership in various areas of the canton. The AANES, with the assistance of former Land Registry employees, has sought to largely maintain the administrative divisions and work procedures that were used by the previous Land Registry, in order to ensure a degree of reliability for the documents it issues.
Despite this, residents still tend to document their real estate sales with a notary public where one is available, and often through customary contracts whose only guarantee lies in the witnesses who attended the sales and signed or affixed their fingerprints to the contracts. This is giving rise to the phenomenon of the “chain of contracts” as a real estate document circulated in buying and selling transactions to preserve rights, despite its weak legal force, and it remains in use to this day.
