Court in Azaz Reinstates Real Estate Sales and Border Licensing Laws
On October 2, the Civil Court of First Instance in the Azaz area of northern Rural Aleppo began implementing the tax imposed by the Real Estate Sales Law No. 15 of 2021, along with the licensing conditions for border areas set out in Law No. 41 of 2004 (as amended by Decree No. 49 of 2008) after a suspension lasting more than 13 years. Under this enforcement, anyone wishing to sell property through the court must present a financial statement indicating the property’s market value, as stipulated by the Real Estate Sales Tax Law, and complete the border-area licensing procedure.
This measure, introduced without any official government circular, has effectively halted most property-sale registration cases and has stirred wide debate among lawyers about its legality and its consistency with the administrative reality of the region.
According to Law No. 15 of 2021, assessing the financial value for real estate sales tax requires determining the market value of the property within its local real estate zone, applying a rate of 1 percent for residential and agricultural properties, 2 percent for industrial ones, and 3 percent for commercial properties. Financial committees formed by the governorate-level finance directorates are responsible for estimating these values.
Although no new government instructions have been issued to enforce these laws in northern Syria, the Civil Court of First Instance in Azaz has begun requiring plaintiffs in property ownership cases to obtain a statement of the property’s market value and complete the border-area licensing procedure before filing their cases. It has also suspended all ongoing civil cases of this type, effectively paralysing the registration of property sale confirmation cases through the court in Azaz, which covers dozens of towns and villages. The court has also demanded that parties complete the border-area licensing process, since Law No. 41 of 2004 and its amendments classify northern Syrian regions adjacent to the Turkish border as border zones. These zones, extending up to 40 kilometres into Syrian territory, are subject to Law No. 41 of 2004 and its subsequent amendments.
To obtain a licence in border areas, one must secure a security clearance from the Ministry of Interior based on recommendations from the Ministries of Defence and Agriculture. During the Assad regime, this process typically took several months and often required the payment of bribes to officials, according to legal sources at the Azaz court.
Several lawyers told The Syria Report that the enforcement of these laws by the Azaz Civil Court represents a personal interpretation by the judge, noting that neighbouring Afrin and the courts in Idlib Governorate do not require a financial statement or border licence. Likewise, the Azaz Land Registry does not ask for these documents when carrying out direct property transfers or registrations. This confirms that there has been no official government circular mandating the implementation of these laws in northern Syria. The result may be inconsistent enforcement across neighbouring regions, undermining legal stability due to the absence of a unified legal framework.
The core problem with applying the Real Estate Sales Tax Law lies in the fact that, as of yet, the Azaz Finance Directorate has not been reactivated, even a year after the fall of the Assad regime. Consequently, obtaining a financial statement showing the market value of a property is impossible. Lawyers raised this issue with the Minister of Justice during his visit to the Azaz Bar Association office in October. A prior meeting had also been held between lawyers and the head of the Aleppo Court of Justice to discuss the problem. Despite promises to find a solution, none has yet materialised.
According to The Syria Report’s local correspondent, some lawyers approached the Aleppo Finance Directorate to request market-value assessments, but the directorate informed them that it lacked sufficient staff to carry out property inspections for valuation in the Azaz area. As a result, the judge of the Azaz Civil Court agreed to allow the registration of cases and to issue rulings confirming sales, but with a suspension on issuing certified copies of the judgments until both the financial statement and the border-licence procedure are completed. Consequently, no original or certified copy of a sale-confirmation ruling can be obtained until the market-value assessment is completed, the real-estate sales tax is paid, and the border-area licence is secured.
From a legal standpoint, this suspension is unlawful. Once a judgment is issued, the winning plaintiff acquires the right to receive the original ruling as proof of ownership. Upon issuance, the case leaves the court’s jurisdiction, and the court no longer has the authority to impose conditions restricting access to the judgment.
Thus, reinstating the border-licensing requirement under the same cumbersome procedures that existed during the Assad era – without simplifying its acquisition – could reopen the door to the corrupt practices that once prevailed, including bribery and the extortion of property owners. Furthermore, the absence of any legal basis for the court’s enforcement of these measures constitutes a restriction on property rights by preventing owners from freely disposing of their property.
